Warren vows no middle-class tax hike for $20T health plan
Moderates call plan ‘mathematical gymnastics’
WASHINGTON — Elizabeth Warren on Friday proposed $20 trillion in federal spending over the next decade to provide health care to every American without raising taxes on the middle class, a risky effort that pits the goal of universal coverage against skepticism of governmentrun health care.
The details of Warren’s “Medicare for All” plan aim to quell criticism that the Massachusetts Democrat and presidential candidate has been vague about how she would pay for her sweeping proposal. Her refusal to say until now whether she would impose new taxes on the middle class, as fellow progressive White House hopeful
Bernie Sanders has said he would, had made her a target in recent presidential debates.
However, her detailed proposal was quickly attacked by moderate rivals, including former Vice President Joe Biden, whose campaign said it amounts to “mathematical gymnastics.” Some independent experts also questioned whether her numbers were realistic.
In a 20-page online post, Warren said a cornerstone of her plan would require employers to transfer to the government almost all the $8.8 trillion she estimates they would otherwise spend on private insurance for employees.
“We can generate almost half of what we need to cover Medicare for All just by asking employers to pay slightly less than they are projected to pay today, and through existing taxes,” she wrote.
Warren said Friday that her plan was drafted with help from top health care experts and economists. “If Joe Biden doesn’t like that … I’m just not sure where he’s going,” she said.
Companies with fewer than 50 employees that don’t already sponsor coverage would be exempt from the proposal. And in a nod to unions, whose support will be key in the Democratic primary, Warren said that employers already offering health benefits under collective bargaining agreements would be allowed to reduce how much they send to federal coffers — provided they pass those savings on to employees.
Biden, who favors building on the Affordable Care Act, slammed Warren’s plan as eliminating private insurance coverage and said it still amounts to a tax increase on workers.