Advocates ask high court to block Texas abortion law
Measure allows citizens to sue to enforce ban after six weeks
WASHINGTON — Abortion rights advocates asked the Supreme Court on Monday to block a Texas law from taking effect this week that allows private individuals to sue to enforce a ban on abortion after about six weeks of pregnancy.
The law incentivizes citizens to sue anyone suspected of helping a woman get an abortion, including people who drive a patient to a Texas clinic or provide financial help. Under the ban, those who successfully sue an abortion provider or health center worker are awarded at least $10,000.
It would be one of the most restrictive abortion laws in the country, effectively outlawing the procedure at a stage before many women are aware that they are pregnant.
Lawyers for abortion providers told the Supreme Court that the law, which is supposed to take effect Wednesday, “would immediately and catastrophically reduce abortion access in Texas” and likely force many clinics to close.
“Patients who can scrape together resources will be forced to attempt to leave the state to obtain an abortion, and many will be delayed until later in pregnancy. The remaining Texans who need an abortion will be forced to remain pregnant against their will or to attempt to end their pregnancies without medical supervision,” the filing states.
The request for intervention comes after an appeals court in Texas abruptly postponed a District Court hearing scheduled for Monday. Opponents of the law had planned to ask a federal judge in Austin to stop the measure from taking effect on Sept. 1.
But the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit called off the hearing in a brief unsigned order. A three-judge panel on Sunday also rejected a request from abortion rights advocates to take the case on an expedited basis or to put the law on hold pending appeal.
The legal developments injected fresh concern and uncertainty for Texas abortion providers, who say the law is unconstitutional and will subject them to endless lawsuits, shut down clinics and reduce services.
More than 85% of women who choose to terminate their pregnancies in Texas are at least six weeks into pregnancy, according to advocates, so the law would prevent nearly all abortions in the state.
“If this law is not blocked by Sept. 1, abortion access in Texas will come to an abrupt stop. Texas has shown it will stop at nothing to force this law into effect and push abortion out of reach for as many Texans as possible,” Marc Hearron, senior counsel at the Center for Reproductive Rights, said in a statement.
Legal experts said advocates still have options, but limited time. Advocates are asking the Supreme Court to block the law or to get rid of the appeals court order and allow the District Court to hold its planned hearing.
Steve Vladeck, a constitutional law professor at the University of Texas School of Law, said there is a “decent chance” there will still be an opportunity for the District Court to convene a hearing and potentially block the law.
“The problem is the chances of that happening before it goes into effect are dwindling by the moment,” Vladeck said. “And for women in Texas who want to avail themselves of their constitutional right to an abortion, that could become virtually impossible by the end of tomorrow night.”
Texas Gov. Greg Abbott, R, signed the legislation in May. Proponents said they are “very optimistic” that the law will take effect as planned, and that the appeals court order means options for stopping the law are now limited.
“To have a significant piece of prolife legislation that takes effect when it was scheduled — that almost never happens,” said John Seago, legislative director at Texas Right to Life, the organization that helped draft the bill. “It’s a phenomenal victory for our movement.”
Abortion opponents nationally are looking to a more conservative Supreme Court to revisit Roe v. Wade’s nearly 50-year guarantee of the right to choose an abortion. The justices this fall will review a restrictive Mississippi ban on almost all abortions after 15 weeks of pregnancy.
A dozen states, including Oklahoma and Idaho, have passed laws similar to Texas’s ban on abortion after about six weeks of pregnancy, dubbing the measures “heartbeat bills” because they say that is when doctors can first detect a fetal heartbeat.
Federal judges have prevented measures in other states from taking effect.