Arkansas Democrat-Gazette

Driven by pious hypocrisy

- Victor Davis Hanson Victor Davis Hanson is a classicist and historian at the Hoover Institutio­n, Stanford University.

Special counsel Robert Mueller’s twoyear, $30 million, 448-page report did not find collusion between Donald Trump and Russia.

Despite compiling private allegation­s of loud and obnoxious Trump behavior, Mueller also concluded that there was not any actionable case of obstructio­n of justice by the president. It would have been hard in any case to find that Trump obstructed Mueller’s investigat­ion of an alleged crime.

1. There was never a crime of collusion. Mueller early on in his endeavors must have realized that truth, but he pressed ahead anyway. It is almost impossible to prove obstructio­n of nothing.

2. Trump cooperated with the investigat­ion. He waived executive privilege. He turned over more than 1 million pages of administra­tive documents. He allowed then-White House counsel Don McGahn to submit to over 30 hours of questionin­g by Mueller’s lawyers.

3. Anyone targeted by a massive investigat­ion who knows he is innocent of a crime is bound to become frustrated over a seemingly never-ending inquisitio­n.

Trump’s reported periodic rages at the Muller investigat­ion are regrettabl­e but not unnatural, given that Mueller expended a huge amount of government resources to confirm what many knew at the outset: There was never any collusion with the Russian government to warp the

2016 election.

Yet Mueller’s team went down every blind alley relating to its investigat­ion—except where Obama-era officials were likely culpable for relevant unethical or illegal behavior.

The Foreign Intelligen­ce Surveillan­ce Act warrants were integral to Mueller’s investigat­ions. But there is no mention of how the FISA court was deceived by not being told that the chief evidence used to obtain the warrants was an unverified dossier paid for in part by the Hillary Clinton campaign and the Democratic National Committee.

Former FBI Director James Comey figures into the Mueller report. But there is no curiosity about whether he broke the law in leaking what may well have been four classified memos of private presidenti­al conversati­ons to the press for the purpose of forcing an appointmen­t of a special counsel.

The Christophe­r Steele dossier likewise makes an appearance in the Mueller report. But for a team investigat­ing the alleged collusion of foreigners in a U.S. election, there is silence about the salient fact that Steele, a foreign national, enlisted other foreign nationals to dig up dirt on Trump to weaken his election chances—with part of the funding for this research provided by the Clinton campaign and the DNC.

What bothers many Americans about the collusion hoax is the accompanyi­ng sanctimony of the so-called investigat­ors.

Comey wrote a memoir, A Higher Loyalty. Its eponymous themes are Comey’s ethics and principles. But Comey may well have misled the FISA court and possibly lied under oath to a House committee. He was not candid with federal investigat­ors and leaked confidenti­al and classified government memos.

Former FBI Director Andrew McCabe also wrote a memoir, The Threat. Its argument is that FBI kingpins such as McCabe protect America from dangers such as Donald Trump. But McCabe himself is under criminal referral for lying to federal investigat­ors. His sworn congressio­nal testimony cannot be reconciled with Comey’s. McCabe also likely misled the FISA court. And he apparently contemplat­ed staging a near-coup to remove an elected president through the deliberate misuse of the 25th Amendment.

Former CIA Director John Brennan is a paid analyst for MSNBC who often railed about Trump’s “treason” and predicted his indictment. Yet Brennan has lied under oath to Congress on two occasions. He likely misled Congress about his role in traffickin­g in the Steele dossiers. And Brennan’s CIA may well have helped the FBI use informants abroad to entrap Trump campaign aides in efforts to find dirt on Trump.

Former Director of National Intelligen­ce James Clapper is a CNN analyst who often predicted that a supposedly treasonous Trump would be indicted. Clapper too has lied to Congress under oath. He once denied and then admitted to leaking confidenti­al documents.

The problem with the Mueller investigat­ion, and with former intelligen­ce officials such as Brennan, Clapper, Comey and McCabe, is pious hypocrisy. Those who have lectured America on Trump’s unproven crimes have written books and appeared on TV to publicize their own superior virtue. Yet they themselves have engaged in all sorts of unethical and illegal behavior.

The only mystery left is whether our elite investigat­ors actually believe their own delusions. Or were they constantly broadcasti­ng their virtue as a preventive defense against growing evidence of their own moral lapses?

 ??  ??
 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States