Court upholds CDC eviction ban
Case heads to Supreme Court; landlords confident of win
WASHINGTON — A federal appeals court Friday said a pause on evictions designed to curb the spread of the coronavirus can remain in place for now, setting up a battle before the nation’s highest court.
A three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia rejected a bid by Alabama and Georgia landlords to block the eviction moratorium reinstated by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention this month.
The landlords plan to immediately file an emergency motion to the Supreme Court, said National Association of Realtors spokesman Patrick Newton.
“With a majority of the Supreme Court in agreement that any further extension of this eviction moratorium requires Congressional authorization, we are confident and hopeful for a quick resolution,” Newton said in an emailed statement.
In a short written decision, the panel said the appeals court had rejected a similar bid and a lower court also declined to overturn the moratorium.
“In view of that decision and on the record before us, we likewise deny the emergency motion directed to this court,” the judges said.
The Supreme Court voted 5-4 in June to allow the moratorium to continue through the end of July. But Justice Brett Kavanaugh — who joined the majority — warned the administration not to act further without explicit congressional approval.
The Biden administration allowed an earlier moratorium to lapse July 31, saying it had no legal authority to allow it to continue. But the CDC issued a new moratorium days later as pressure mounted from lawmakers and others to help vulnerable renters stay in their homes as the coronavirus’ delta variant surged. The new moratorium is scheduled to expire Oct. 3.
As of Aug. 2, roughly 3.5 million people in the U.S. said they faced eviction in the next two months, according to the Census Bureau’s Household Pulse Survey.
The new moratorium temporarily halted evictions in counties with “substantial and high levels” of virus transmissions, covering areas where 90% of the U.S. population lives.
The Trump administration initially put a nationwide eviction moratorium in place last year out of fear that people who couldn’t pay their rent would end up in crowded living conditions such as in homeless shelters and help spread the virus.
President Joe Biden acknowledged there were questions about the legality of the new eviction freeze. But he said a court fight would buy time for the distribution of some of the $45 billion in rental assistance that has been approved but not yet used.
In urging the appeals court to keep the ban in place, the Biden administration noted that the new moratorium was more targeted than the nationwide ban that had lapsed, and that the landscape had changed since the Supreme Court ruling because of the spread of the highly contagious delta variant.
The landlords accused the administration of caving in to political pressure and reinstating the moratorium even though it knew it was illegal.
“As the President himself has acknowledged, the CDC’s latest extension is little more than a delay tactic designed to buy time to distribute rental assistance,” their attorneys wrote in court documents.
A lower-court judge ruled this month that the freeze is illegal but rejected the landlords’ request to lift the moratorium, saying her hands were tied by an appellate decision from the last time courts considered the evictions moratorium in the spring.