Baptists fund abuse inquiry, keep privilege
NASHVILLE, Tenn. — A top Southern Baptist Convention committee has agreed to fund a third-party investigation into its handling of sexual abuse allegations but held off on waiving its attorney-client privilege for the inquiry, delaying a decision on what’s seen as a key demand of the thousands of Southern Baptists who set the review in motion.
The Executive Committee on Tuesday allocated $1.6 million for Guidepost Solutions, the firm conducting the investigation into allegations that the panel mishandled abuse cases, resisted making changes and intimidated survivors and advocates.
“I think it’s a good step, and I think that it shows our unity on the urgency of the matter,” Executive Committee Chairman Rolland Slade said.
The decision came at the end of the Executive Committee’s two-day business meeting in Nashville. The investigation, including the question of whether the Executive Committee would waive its attorney-client privilege, dominated discussion. The rule protects the confidentiality of communications on legal advice, and some Executive Committee members raised concerns that waiving it could affect litigation and insurance policies.
Delegates, also known as messengers, voted overwhelmingly at their national gathering in June to create a task force tasked with overseeing the third-party investigation.
They also directed the task force to agree to the investigator’s recommended standards and best practices, “including but not limited to the Executive Committee staff and members waiving attorney-client privilege in order to ensure full access to information and accuracy in the review.” In August, the task force formally asked the Executive Committee to waive it, saying it is the will of the messengers and is critical to the investigation.
On Monday and Tuesday, Executive Committee members heard from key stakeholders about the investigation, asked questions about the risks of waiving privilege and disagreed over how much of this week’s discussions should happen in private.
Julie Myers Wood, the CEO of Guidepost Solutions, told the Executive Committee that waiving privilege is the “only way to ensure that the investigation is viewed as fully credible, transparent and thorough and to show that the EC has and the Southern Baptist Convention has nothing to hide.”
On Tuesday, the members took hours to hash out what they ultimately approved, which included asking the task force and Executive Committee officers to come up with a contract in seven days that did not waive attorney-client privilege.
After the vote, Executive Committee member Joe Knott of North Carolina said members have a legal responsibility to be good stewards of the institution.
“Anyone who does harm to anyone else should be exposed and full courts of law brought down upon them. No one wants to cover up any crime,” Knott said. “However, there are also laws that govern fiduciary responsibility, and we don’t want to break those laws either.”
Southern Baptist Convention President Ed Litton said in a statement that Tuesday’s decision by the Executive Committee fell short of the mandate the delegates gave in June.
“I’m disappointed that several known issues are only now being addressed with appropriate seriousness, but I’m grateful the investigation will begin,” Litton said.
The investigation into the Executive Committee is expected to take several months.
A written report of the findings is due to the task force before Southern Baptists meet in June for their annual denominational meeting.
The report is expected to be made public along with recommendations from the task force about the next steps the convention should take.