Fact-checking UN secretary-general’s report on catastrophic hunger in Gaza
In Gaza, experts and journalists say, food is running out.
Some people are making “bread” from animal feed ground into a flour or “soup” from water and weeds, according to news reports. But even those food sources are being exhausted, warned experts who evaluate food insecurity and famine.
“Palestinians in Gaza are enduring horrifying levels of hunger and suffering,” U.N. Secretary-General António Guterres said March 18. “This is the highest number of people facing catastrophic hunger ever recorded by the Integrated Food Security Classification system – anywhere, anytime.”
A March 18 report by a group of international organizations that evaluate global food emergencies found that “famine is imminent” in parts of Gaza.
Using the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification system, the report estimated that from mid-March to midJuly, 1.1 million people – about half of Gaza’s population – will face “catastrophic” food insecurity, when starvation, death and “extremely critical acute malnutrition levels” are evident.
From Feb. 15 to March 15, the report said, 677,000 people in Gaza faced “catastrophic” levels of food insecurity.
The Israel-Hamas war and “extremely limited” access for humanitarian groups to provide aid within Gaza are driving the hunger crisis, the report said.
Guterres’ statement is specific and accurate. We found no instances since the tracking system’s creation about two decades ago in which more people in one place were classified as experiencing “catastrophic” hunger or famine. At the same time, his statement might have left some listeners, particularly those unfamiliar with this 20-year-old global tracking system, wondering how the Gaza situation compares with other hunger crises throughout history.
We contacted Guterres and a spokesperson with the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification system and received no reply. Data and experts backed Guterres’ statement.
Ron Dermer, minister for strategic affairs in Israel, on March 26 disputed the report of imminent famine.
The Integrated Food Security Phase Classification system Guterres referred to, created in 2004, is used to classify “the severity and magnitude of food insecurity and malnutrition” globally.
The system, sometimes called IPC, is described as the main tool the international community uses to analyze data and determine whether famine is happening or projected to occur in a country.
“This is an exercise that has about 23 partners, including 19 U.N. agencies and international (nongovernmental organizations) and about four donors,” Arif Husain, the United Nations World Food Program chief economist, told The New Yorker. He said the group’s findings are independent and a consensusbased analysis.
The IPC’s system classifies acute food insecurity in five phases, with 1 meaning “none/minimal,” to 5, meaning “catastrophe/famine.” Since the system’s creation, food insecurity levels have rarely reached phase 5 in any country.
The “catastrophic” phase 5 classification applies to households experiencing extreme lack of food. A phase 5 “famine” classification applies to an area in which at least 1 in 5 households face “catastrophic” food insecurity, and malnutrition and mortality are acute.
IPC has classified two situations in the last 10 years as “famine:”
In 2011 in parts of southern Somalia, about 490,000 people experienced catastrophic food insecurity because of conflict and drought.
In 2017, almost 80,000 people in parts of South Sudan faced acute food insecurity because of three years of civil war, economic hardship and high food prices.
In January, de Waal said the IPC phase 5 designation “is exceptional and rare.”
Based on the information we could find, 677,000 people facing catastrophic hunger, as the report said they are in Gaza, is unprecedented.
We searched Google and Nexis, a database of news reports, and found other instances in which acute food insecurity reached phase 5 catastrophic levels, even if the IPC did not designate a famine. These included:
In June 2021, 353,000 people in Ethiopia. (The Ethiopian government disputed the analysis.)
In March 2022, 31,000 people in Yemen.
In May 2022, 20,000 people in Afghanistan.
In October 2022, 19,000 people in Haiti.
n November 2023, 35,000 people in South Sudan.
Beth Bechdol, the Food and Agriculture Organization’s deputy director general, told The Washington Post that, as of the March report, Gaza has the largest percentage of a population to receive its most severe rating since the IPC began reporting in 2004.
The report said 30% of Gaza’s population is currently in phase 5.
The World Peace Foundation’s de
Waal, who wrote the book “Mass Starvation: The History and Future of Famine,” told PolitiFact that someone would have to look back to before World War II to find incidents of food insecurity “of comparable intensity.”
“The absolute numbers of people who will die in Gaza’s catastrophe will not match the great and calamitous famines of the 20th century, solely because the afflicted population is smaller,” he wrote in January. “The proportionate death toll may be comparable.”
The IPC system has been used in at least 30 countries but is not used everywhere – so it has not designated catastrophic hunger or famine in places such as Syria, where conflict has caused significant food insecurity for millions of people.
And the most dire situations are also those in which data is hardest to gather, said Erin Lentz, a University of Texas public affairs professor who studies food insecurity.
In Gaza, “it’s really difficult to get a handle on what’s happening with mortality rates,” which is a component of a famine classification, Lentz said.
The Sudan situation is similar, she said. Conflict between Sudan’s military and a violent paramilitary group has put the country at risk of becoming the world’s largest hunger crisis, according to the U.N.
IPC classifications, which require a group of analysts to reach consensus, also take time, Lentz said.
“So not only is it hard to collect data, but in places like Gaza and in Sudan, the situation is so dynamic, the data are often out of date pretty quickly,” she said.
Politifact’s ruling
Guterres said Gaza has “the highest number of people facing catastrophic hunger ever recorded” by the IPC system “anywhere, anytime.”
He’s right about the IPC system’s data. A March report using the IPC system found that 677,000 Gazans currently face catastrophic acute food insecurity and projected that 1.1 million people are expected to face such acute food insecurity from March 16 to July 15.
It’s worth noting that the IPC system is not used in every country. But we found no instances in which more than 677,000 people were classified as experiencing “catastrophic” hunger or famine in any one location since the system’s creation in 2004.
Guterres’ statement is accurate, so we rate it True.