Are river cruises better than ocean cruises?
Europe has no shortage of marquee tourist hot spots, but Diamond Meadows’ first river cruise there didn’t include them.
The 28-year-old graduate student took a cruise along the Rhine and Moselle rivers that took her to cities like Koblenz and Trier in Germany (she supplemented the sailing with train travel around Austria, Switzerland and elsewhere).
Meadows was traveling with her mom and her mom’s boss, who uses a wheelchair. The group chose the CroisiEurope Cruises sailing for the ease of sailing with a mobility device. But she discovered other upsides.
“It takes you exactly into the heart of the city,” said Meadows, who is based in Tennessee. Their roughly 160-guest vessel offered convenient drop-offs in smaller destinations, allowing them “to access so much more.”
Many European destinations were packed with tourists last summer. But river cruises in the continent can offer a more laid-back way to travel with small ships visiting a mix of popular and lesscrowded ports.
Jen Campbell Boles, founder of the travel agency Explore More Family Travel, said that while cruising in general is a “great value for seeing Europe,” river sailings are particularly immersive. “One quote we always use in the travel industry is, ‘Ocean cruise liners take you to the destination, river cruises take us through the destination,’” she said.
Passengers visit not only major cities but also quaint villages and often disembark within walking distance of attractions. When they are done exploring, they return to a ship with an average of 150 guests.
“It’s more intimate, it’s cozier,” said Campbell Boles. “You’re not fighting the crowds, obviously.”
That was part of the draw for Jim Jones, 57, who took Avalon Waterways river cruises with his wife in 2011 and 2014.
“The smaller cities were an attraction,” said Jones, who is based in Phoenix and works for a software company. He enjoyed visiting Avignon in the south of France, for example, which was once the seat of the papacy. “I’m a total history geek,” he said. On their first cruise, he recalled, “just about every town” they visited had a farmers’ market, allowing them to sample local food.
Unlike ocean cruise ships, with their large casinos and plentiful bars, onboard “it was very relaxed and a much slower pace.”
River cruise vessels tend to have “less bells and whistles,” Campbell Boles said (though she added that guests get a more personalized experience as a result of their small size).
Adam Duckworth, president and founder of Travelmation, echoed that. He said the cruises are less about the ship than where it’s going. “This is truly an experience about itineraries.”
Are they cheaper than land-based trips?
While travelers can find land-based accommodations that are less expensive than river cruises, there are other factors to consider.
River cruises tend to bundle more costs, such as alcohol in the fare, than a mainstream ocean cruise line, Duckworth said (though exact policies vary by line). At least one excursion per day is typically included, as well, Campbell Boles added.
She said demand for Europe is still “through the roof ” and land-based pricing is particularly high. “Even if you’re staying in the highest category stateroom or suite, you’re spending less than an equivalent hotel,” she said.
Transportation from one destination to another is also built into a river cruise, whereas travelers might have to take a train or make other arrangements to visit a mix of places. “I mean that really adds up in Europe, so this is a great way to see a lot more variety,” Campbell Boles said.
Passengers can also add pre- and post-cruise stays, allowing them to “get the best of both worlds.”
“What we say is that a river cruise oftentimes can be a premium product,” added Duckworth. “But for what you’re experiencing – the comfort, the (lower) stress, the luxurious experience on board – we find it to be actually the best value through Europe from our experience.”
Are they kid-friendly?
Since river cruises require a certain amount of free time – most are at least seven days long – they have tended to be popular with older guests, according to
Duckworth.
But in the past couple of years, he has noticed more multigenerational travel in the sector. “We’re seeing grandparents bring their grandkids, we’re seeing young professionals go on a river in Europe for the first time,” Duckworth said.
Some operators have offerings that are particularly well-suited to younger guests. Adventures by Disney offers river cruises with AmaWaterways, and Uniworld Boutique River Cruises has a Generations Collection.
Even if programming is curated with kids in mind, though, Duckworth cautioned that river cruise vessels don’t offer the same breadth of amenities as large ocean ships. “If your kids want to go to a waterpark and they want to go on a FlowRider and they want to play putt-putt all day, there are great lines for you, but a European river cruise is probably not one of them currently,” he said.
Some lines also don’t allow kids or have varying age requirements, so it’s important to do some research beforehand.
For those going for the first time, Campbell Boles suggested starting with a cruise on the Danube or Rhine since they are “kind of the most iconic.”
“I mean, it’s Europe,” she added. “It’s going to be great no matter what river you go on.”