Anti-democratic trends take root thanks to US arrogance
It was one of those uncanny nights when everything blurs and then clarifies.
It was July 20, 2017, and my family had just arrived in Warsaw, Poland. A protest march was underway in defense of an independent judiciary, so we joined it.
As the march proceeded down a long boulevard toward the presidential palace, I put my daughter, then 5, on my shoulders. The route was long, and I had just about given up when a bicycle taxi appeared and gave us a ride, for free, to the edge of the woods around the palace.
Now in the dark, we walked hand in hand through the trees toward a voice I heard projected by microphone.
I had a dreamy sense that the words were familiar: A protester, I realized, was reading aloud from a Polish translation of my book “On Tyranny: Lessons From the Twentieth Century,” which had been published a few months earlier. It was lesson No. 2, “defend institutions.”
I am a historian of Eastern Europe, and I wrote “On Tyranny” in response to the American presidential election of 2016, informed by what I have learned from the European past about how democracies fall and how individuals can respond. It was meant to help Americans recognize patterns of oppression in time to act.
It did reach Americans, which was gratifying. But to my surprise it also reached back into Eastern Europe. In Poland the book was read aloud in protests throughout the country. It was even recorded as rap in 2019.
Some of the lessons, like No. 10 (“believe in truth”) were inspired by my contemporaries. Serhiy Zhadan is an extraordinary Ukrainian creator of culture: novelist, poet and singer in a ska band. In 2014, when Russia invaded Ukraine, he took to the internet to work against Russian propaganda. At the time, Russian soldiers, mercenaries and nationalists were pouring across the Ukrainian border, creating the appearance of civil unrest in east Ukrainian cities such as Kharkiv, where he lives. Mr. Zhadan joined a group of locals who tried to defend city buildings.
He was beaten and told to kneel. When he refused, attackers broke his skull.
He recovered and so did his city. In June 2017, just before I left for that trip to Poland, I went to New York see his band. They had added a song to their repertoire: a cover of the Clash’s “Know Your Rights” in which Mr. Zhadan included the 20 lessons of my book in the lyrics.
At the time, people around the world
were looking for ways to articulate threats to democracy that had no clear name and to find words that would describe their own action. In this, the book played a modest part.
It found its way onto posters in Brazil, into Parliament in India, into peacekeeping missions in Syria, into protests everywhere. In Hong Kong, defenders of human rights affixed stickers with the lessons around the city. On the sticker of lesson No. 1, “do not obey in advance,” was a person refusing to kneel.
Tyrants draw lessons from the past and from one another, and those who oppose them must do the same. If we want to grasp what is happening in time to make a difference, we need to know the patterns.
In China and Russia the regimes deliberately undermine political values.
Globalization is exploited by tyrants to put an enemy’s face on unpredictability. Ecological catastrophes are used by tyrants to divide societies and to blame the victims. Social media platforms are used to organize and energize the backlash to democratic movements. Increasing economic and social inequalities further distort national conversations. And cowardly politicians and judges, with a moral blindness to the threats to
freedom, concede rights to an empty legalism.
Democracy rises and falls globally. To believe that America is exceptional, democratic by nature, is only to aid the tyrants. It is this very arrogance about our own country that has made us so vulnerable to anti-democratic trends.
“We did not listen in 2016 when others warned us of patterns they observed in our country. If you think what you do is democratic because of who you are, you will not notice when you help to bring about tyranny. America is only as exceptional as we make it. That is lesson No. 8, “stand out.”
If we want to be heard around the world, we should listen — especially to those who have taken greater risks than we have and in worse circumstances.