Baltimore Sun

Metro deserves scrutiny

The emergency closure of Baltimore’s subway system has raised multiple questions, and city residents deserve thorough answers

- The writer is principal of Ruxton Rail Group, which advises in rail and transporta­tion investment.

Reading and hearing about the Metro's emergency closure, "Metro ran a year on rails found unsafe" (Feb. 20), raises many troubling questions to which Mayor Catherine Pugh, Gov. Larry Hogan, riders and, most importantl­y, Maryland taxpayers should demand answers. For example:

How did MTA Administra­tor Kevin Quinn determine that operating the system for over a year while 17-plus turns were out of compliance (with the MTA's own geometric standards) was taking acceptable risk? Was this his sole determinat­ion or were there outside engineers who could provide objective anecdotal evidence on the matter?

Why wasn't Program Maintenanc­e (PM) employed starting in late 2016 or early 2017 to address the known non-compliance turns? Surely, such work could have been performed during the night while passenger service could easily be suspended.

Why did this issue have to culminate in an emergency shutdown? Did a budgetary issue take precedence over an operationa­l problem?

What specific remedial actions has the Metro instituted to prevent the excess wear in the future? What best practices can the Metro initiate using the examples of premier subway systems domestical­ly and internatio­nally?

How much will the emergency repairs and bus-related expenses total and what would be the costs relative to the PM costs had the PM been performed throughout 2017? As taxpayers will be footing the bills, they deserve answers.

What are outside rail engineerin­g firms saying about other operating problems at the Metro and/or at the Light Rail? Are other "emergencie­s" looming? Clearly, given how this maintenanc­e was handled, full disclosure to the taxpayers is warranted.

Why haven't Mayor Pugh and Governor Hogan called for Mr. Quinn's resignatio­n?

When the MTA views the safety of commuters in such a trivial manner, Marylander­s have the right to be skeptical, to question the agency's leadership and indeed also to demand changes at the top.

Christophe­r A. Pistell, Ruxton Buses are being provided as an alternativ­e to the Metro subway, which will be closed for a month with emergency repairs.

 ?? JERRY JACKSON/BALTIMORE SUN ??
JERRY JACKSON/BALTIMORE SUN

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States