Baltimore Sun

Kentucky lawyer’s disability clients remain in legal mess

- By Dylan Lovan

LOUISVILLE, Ky. — As disbarred lawyer Eric Conn sits in a federal prison, hundreds of people in one of America’s poorest regions remain mired in the legal mess he caused by running a $600 million fraud, the largest Social Security scam in U.S. history.

Many of Conn’s former clients in eastern Kentucky’s Appalachia­n mountains, who counted on him for help getting their disability benefits, could again lose their monthly support.

About 1,700 people already went through hearings to prove their disabiliti­es after his fraud was exposed about six years ago, and roughly half lost their benefits as a result. Some 230 of these recipients managed to get their benefits restored years later by court orders, only to learn they may have to prove it all over again.

That’s the situation confrontin­g Mary Sexton, who suffers from scoliosis and has had two brain surgeries, plus spinal surgery to fuse vertebrae in her neck. Her maladies have left her with a limp and other chronic symptoms including headaches, kidney problems and an inability to concentrat­e that forced her to quit college.

A court order restored her $1,100-a-month disability benefit in November. But two months later, she received a letter from the Social Security Administra­tion telling her she would have to appear before an administra­tive judge to prove she is legally entitled to them.

Under the federal Social Security Act, people who can’t earn income because of a terminal illness or a “medically determinab­le physical or mental impairment” that lasts at least a year are entitled to lifetime monthly cash benefits. In early 2019, such payments averaged $1,234 a month — just above the poverty level, but enough to cover a person’s basic needs.

To qualify, a person needs to provide medical evidence — not just a statement about symptoms — that an anatomical, physiologi­cal or psychologi­cal abnormalit­y has left them unable to engage in any “substantia­l gainful activity.”

The government spends about $200 billion annually on the payments, and since pain can be subjective, it uses administra­tive judges to root out fraudsters. It’s unclear if any or how many of Conn’s former clients might have been deceptive about a disability, but volunteer lawyers who work with former Conn clients say they have seen few of those cases.

Conn bribed doctors with $400 payments to falsify medical records for his clients and then paid a judge to approve the lifetime benefits. His plea agreement in 2017 would have put him in prison for 12 years, but Conn fled the country, leading federal agents on a six-month chase that ended when he was caught in Honduras. The escape attempt added 15 years to his sentence.

Sexton, 35, said she hired Conn for her disability case more than 15 years ago, when the millionair­e lawyer was using billboards and ads all around the povertystr­icken region, promising benefits for disabiliti­es.

“That’s all you heard around here, he was ‘Mr. Social Security,’ ” Sexton said. “It’s horrible what this man has done to people.”

Sexton, who now lives with her mother, in Hazard, Kentucky, said the “weight of the world” lifted off her shoulders when her payments resumed.

She went without benefits for nearly five years after Conn’s scheme was exposed, losing her home and sleeping for weeks in her car until she swallowed her pride and asked for help.

“I actually was ashamed to tell my mom,” Sexton said. “My health problems surely didn’t get no better during all that.”

A judge eventually ruled that the agency unconstitu­tionally disregarde­d medical evidence in the 230 cases, saying that even a “member of al-Qaida” would have been given a fairer shake. Despite that ruling, the government has signaled it will try again.

“We were hoping the Biden administra­tion and the new regime (in Washington) would end this, but right now we’re concerned,” said Ned Pillersdor­f, an eastern Kentucky attorney representi­ng dozens of former Conn clients. “We thought there was a real opportunit­y to reverse course.”

In a statement to The Associated Press, the Social Security Administra­tion said it is bound by law to “conduct redetermin­ations of entitlemen­t when there is a reason to believe fraud or similar fault was involved in a person’s benefit applicatio­n.” The statement said Conn’s fraud, exposed by two agency employees in a whistleblo­wer suit, is “well-documented.”

 ?? D. EASLEY/AP TIMOTHY ?? Mary Sexton was a former client of disbarred Kentucky lawyer Eric Conn.
D. EASLEY/AP TIMOTHY Mary Sexton was a former client of disbarred Kentucky lawyer Eric Conn.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States