Boston Herald

The silence is telling

State holding back on critical virus data – unless pushed hard

- Joe Battenfeld

The Baker administra­tion appears to have withheld critical data about “breakthrou­gh” coronaviru­s deaths for days — and only released the informatio­n because of a Herald public records request.

This is not good enough. It smells like an attempted cover-up.

The public deserves to know as quickly as possible how many fully vaccinated people are contractin­g the virus.

It took the Department of Public Health 10 days — the longest they could go under the law — to answer the Herald public records request.

Only after being pushed by the request did the Baker administra­tion then release the data to all media. It turns out that there were a total of 4,450 breakthrou­gh cases out of more than 4 million vaccinated people.

Why? What is the DPH afraid of ? A bad news cycle?

The truth is that most of the media lapdogs dutifully rehashed the DPH press release to put the best spin possible on the fact that 79 fully vaccinated people died of COVID. The Boston Globe included the 79 dead in the fourth paragraph, preferring to say in the lead that only .1% of vaccinated people got the virus.

It’s fair to say that those numbers are actually pretty good. It shows the vaccine is mostly working.

But it’s little consolatio­n to the 79 families that are now grieving the loss of loved ones who did their duty and got vaccinated.

The vaccine is not foolproof, and that’s what is worrying about the death totals. We were told earlier that even if vaccinated people did get the virus, it would lead to only minor symptoms. Now we know that’s not exactly true.

And despite the release of the COVID death and illness numbers, we still don’t know details about who exactly is getting sick and dying. Is it the elderly? People with previous conditions? Or totally healthy people?

We just don’t know. When it comes to the deadly coronaviru­s, knowledge is power. Numbers and data are critical to let people know whether it’s safe to not wear masks, go back to restaurant­s again and attend sporting events.

With the 2022 gubernator­ial election looming, these death and illness totals are important informatio­n that could impact how voters think about Gov. Charlie Baker’s handling of the coronaviru­s.

Baker goes out almost daily and holds feel-good events designed to promote the vaccine. The governor did not announce the 79 fatal breakthrou­gh cases. No surprise there.

The apparent withholdin­g of the breakthrou­gh case numbers is just the latest questionab­le decision by the Baker administra­tion.

The DPH resisted releasing informatio­n about the specific case numbers in cities and towns in Massachuse­tts, and only after critics called for the release did the administra­tion cough it up.

Then of course there’s the terrible tragedy and deadly dysfunctio­n at the Holyoke Soldiers’ Home, and the slow initial rollout of the vaccine, complete with a website crash. The administra­tion’s highly touted contact tracing program was a complete waste of money, and the vaccine lottery appears to be a bust, too.

 ?? Pool File pHoTo ?? SPEAK NO EVIL: Gov. Charlie Baker holds frequent feel-good events, but has said nothing about the rise of ‘breakthrou­gh’ COVID cases that have killed 79 fully vaccinated Bay State residents and sickened a total of 4,450.
Pool File pHoTo SPEAK NO EVIL: Gov. Charlie Baker holds frequent feel-good events, but has said nothing about the rise of ‘breakthrou­gh’ COVID cases that have killed 79 fully vaccinated Bay State residents and sickened a total of 4,450.
 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States