Jolted by mutiny, Putin works crowds
Looks to prove public support remains strong
He worked a throng of screaming fans in Dagestan. He hoisted a young girl onto his hip in Kronstadt. He posed shoulder-to-shoulder with seven young siblings, shaking their father’s hand after a military parade.
President Vladimir Putin of Russia is newly out and about, pressing the flesh of the Russian people, in a bid to demonstrate that his years of pandemic-induced isolation are over and that his public support remains strong despite the war in Ukraine and a failed mutiny against his government.
His behavior is a noticeable change for the Russian president, who cultivated extreme seclusion during the pandemic, forcing visiting leaders to sit at the opposite end of giant oblong tables and requiring people to quarantine for up to two weeks to see him.
The isolation persisted until well after politicians elsewhere had dispensed with such precautions amid receding fears about COVID-19. And once Russia invaded Ukraine, Putin’s distance stood in stark contrast to President Volodymyr Zelensky of Ukraine, who made regular visits to front-line positions, crowded ceremonies, and cramped hospital rooms.
Though many precautions remain in place, and Putin hardly rivals President Biden on an Iowa rope line, the Russian leader is noticeably interacting with crowds in orchestrated appearances — portraying himself as in touch and in charge after the rebellion by the Wagner private militia suggested that he was neither.
“What about the quarantine?” a journalist called out to Putin last month as the Russian leader worked a crowd in Kronstadt. “The people are more important than quarantine,” Putin shot back.
Putin has long loathed populist retail politics, deriding the sort of baby kissing required of American politicians as frivolous and vulgar.
His attempts at impromptu interaction with the Russian populace over the years have often come off as wooden or peculiar, such as when he lifted the shirt of a young boy and kissed his belly in a 2006 appearance at the Kremlin. (Putin later said he had wanted to cuddle him like a kitten, a discordant image for a former KGB lieutenant colonel.)
The Russian leader has preferred more controlled events, often inspecting production facilities and meeting with worker collectives, holding court over subordinate officials, presiding over military ceremonies, or cutting the image of a rugged outdoorsman in carefully orchestrated publicity stunts.
Much of that active image fell away with the pandemic, when Putin began to come across as more of a withdrawn autocrat — beaming in from behind a desk over a flatscreen, at one point to launch an ill-planned war.
But an aborted June 24 mutiny by Yevgeny Prigozhin, the mercenary tycoon, seems to have changed the calculation.
Days after Prigozhin’s uprising, Putin traveled to Derbent, a city in Russia’s southern Dagestan region, and appeared before a crowd screaming with delight — a boisterous encounter the likes of which Russia had not seen from its leader in years.
His spokesperson later said that Putin had gone against the “strong recommendations from experts” and made a “firm decision” to interact with the crowd, because “he couldn’t refuse these people and not greet them.”
Tatiana Stanovaya, a senior fellow at the Carnegie Russia Eurasia Center, said the decision to work the crowd was almost certainly Putin’s personal choice — designed in part to send the message to Russia’s elite that he maintains the adoration of the nation’s public.
“Prigozhin’s rebellion — that was the strongest blow to the legitimacy of the leadership,” Stanovaya said. “And where does legitimacy come from? From the people. Therefore, the desire to throw oneself into the people and feel you are supported, it’s the kind of need that arises against the backdrop of a rebellion.”
Putin’s appearances with crowds have continued in the days since.
On July 23, he took Belarusian President Alexander Lukashenko to Kronstadt, a city on an island outside St. Petersburg known for its early-20th-century history of mutinies. The two leaders mingled with a crowd outside a cathedral, where Putin stood between a bride and groom. He lifted a smiling girl with sunglasses on her head.
Days later, Putin hosted top African leaders in St. Petersburg, his home city.
If the summit, with its limited roster of African heads of state, failed to solve Russia’s geopolitical isolation, it did address the enduring images of Putin’s physical isolation. In a marathon of photo ops, meetings, and excursions, he had perhaps more sustained personal contact than at any time since before the pandemic, certainly with international officials.
Putin glad-handed African leaders of all levels as well as their spouses, hosted a gala, and entertained some officials who stayed on for Russia’s traditional Navy Day parade of warships on the Neva River. He returned to Kronstadt flanked by Russian defense officials and African leaders on a crowded boat.
In recent days, Putin has alternated between appearances that address the war and interactions with crowds that seem designed to communicate normalcy and demonstrate that he retains the population’s loyalty, even as the war causes continued hardship that has fueled discontent for many Russians.
On Wednesday, he appeared before widows whose husbands had died in the war, brushing his hand over the head of a fallen soldier’s young daughter and patting the shoulder of a boy.
By the standards of most world politicians, Putin’s encounters with crowds are still limited. Zelensky, by comparison, follows a schedule packed with public interactions. A busy American presidential candidate might interact with more public crowds in a week than Putin has in the past year.
But by the Russian leader’s recent standards, the change is noticeable.