Shortage of direct care professionals a concern
Last week, at the Senate Dirksen Building, Room SD-562, Chairman Bob Casey, of the U.S. Special Committee on Aging, (D-PA), showcased S. 4120, legislation that he introduced with U.S. Senators Tim Kaine (D-VA), and Tammy Baldwin (D-WI). The Long-Term Care Workforce Support Act, introduced during the 118th Congress, would ensure that direct care professionals have a sustainable, lifelong career by providing substantial new funding to support these workers in every part of the long-term care industry, from nursing homes to home carne, tdo assisted living facilities.
The Senate Aging Committee details a number of statistical findings showing the need for Congress to address the nation’s severe ongoing direct care professional workforce shortage. “A recent survey revealed 92% of nursing facility respondents and nearly 70% of assisted living facilities reported significant or severe workforce shortages.
In 2022, a survey of nursing facilities showed more than 50% of the facilities were limiting the number of new admissions due to staffing vacancies or shortages. Another recent survey of Home and Community Based Service providers showed that all 50 states were experiencing home care worker shortages, and 43 states reported that some HCBS provider groups have closed due to worker shortages,” says the fact sheet.
Addressing the cause
SBy improving compensation, benefits, and support systems, S.4120 would ensure the United States has a “strong, qualified pipeline of workers to provide desperately needed care for older adults and people with disabilities.” notes a statement announcing the introduction of Casey’s legislative proposal.
Specifically, S. 4120 would increase the number of direct care professionals, especially in rural communities. It also would provide pathways to enter and be supported in the workforce for women, people of color, and people with disabilities.
S. 4120 would also improve wage compensation for direct care professionals to reduce vacancies and turnover. It ensures that direct care professionals are treated with respect, provided with a safe working environment, protected from exploitation, and provided fair compensation.
The legislative proposal also documents the need for long-term care, identify effective recruitment and training strategies, and promote practices that help retain direct care professionals. It also would strengthen the direct care professional workforce in order to support the 53,000,000 unpaid family caregivers who are providing complex services to their loved ones in the home and across long-term care settings.
At press time, S. 4120 is endorsed by 50 organizations, including Domestic Workers Alliance, SEIU, AFSCME, Caring Across Generations, National Coalition on Aging (NCOA), Justice in Aging, National Partnership for Women & Families, National Council on Independent Living (NCIL), and the National Disability Rights Network (NDRN).
And a companion legislative proposal was introduced in the House by Congresswoman Debbie Dingell (D-MI).
Senate Aging Committee puts spotlight on Direct Care Staffing Shortage
The April 16th hearing entitled, “The Long-Term Care Workforce: Addressing Shortages and Improving the Profession,” examined the challenges currently facing long-term care workers who are often underpaid and overworked, leading to widespread worker shortages that threaten the availability of care for those who need it.
“It’s a crisis that stems largely from a lack of support for and investment in our caregiving workforce,” warns Casey in his opening statement. “Between 50 to over 90 percent of longterm care settings and providers report significant staffing shortages, affecting their ability to provide services, accept new clients, or even to remain open,”
HERB WEISS
Bhe says.
Casey noted that many direct care professionals have to work multiple jobs or overtime just to be able to support themselves and their families. In 2022, their medium wage was just above $15 dollars an hour, well below what is paid for warehouse and convenience store jobs, per Casey.
“The direct care workforce, the majority of whom are women of color, are more likely to live in poverty compared to the general public,” notes Casey.
“Cumbersome federal regulations, requirements, and protections” and a “onesize fits all approach” won’t fix the direct care staffing shortage, responds Ranking Member Mike Braun (R-IN).
“To grow the long-term care workforce, the federal government should make it easier for people to enter by removing barriers,” says Braun, in his opening statement, calling for “productive approaches to build and grow the care professions.”
Overworked and not enough money
Nicholas Smith, a direct support professional at SPIN, a Pennsylvania-based organization that provides lifespan services for over 3,000 people with intellectual disabilities and autism, came to testify. “I work nearly 65-70 hours a week… due to my work, I have missed family events, nieces’ and nephews’ recitals, and school functions… a lot of people are leaving this field to make more money,” said the Philadelphia resident who has worked in the long-term care industry for over 25 years.
According to Smith, the national average for direct service professional wages is only $15.43 in long-term care. “We spend time training new hires only to lose them because they cannot make a living wage,” he says, noting that other industries are offering more money.
“While people want to stay in this field, they cannot make ends meet. Pennsylvania has a long waitlist for home and community-based services, and this is due to the workforce crisis,” he says.
In her testimony, Brooke Vogleman, a licensed Practical Nurse with Huntington, Indiana based TLC Management, stated: “I’ve seen what happens when long-term care facilities lack workers, resources and government support, like during the pandemic. Many of my colleagues got burned out and left the profession, forcing facilities to rely on costly temporary staffing agencies.”
Vogleman called on federal policy makers, including members of the Senate Aging Committee, to address the challenge through “targeted investments, not blanket mandates.”
For instance, she told the Senators that LPNs are integral to the facility’s interdisciplinary team. “Staffing mandates that do not include our contributions to patient care or recognize us as nurses are very concerning to me and will have unintended consequences on residents,” she says.
Staffing mandates will force facilities to depend more on expensive staffing agencies, warns Vogleman. “Personally, I’m concerned they will actually increase staff burnout, as current caregivers will be stretched thin and working longer hours in order to comply with these impossible standards,” she says.
Matthew Connell, Ed.D., of Ivy Tech Community College of Indiana, came to share the work and achievements of his community college in addressing the shortage of healthcare and long-term care workers in Indiana.
According to Connell, serving more than 190,000 students at 19 campuses and 26 satellite locations as well as on-line, graduates more associate level nurses in Indiana. Nearly half of these students are pursuing college credit while in high school. Ivy Tech is the nation’s single largest provider of dual credit.
Ivy Tech’s programs are especially designed to help graduates enter the workforce quickly and provide critical services for the state’s long-term care population at a tuition rate that is the lowest in the state, he notes. “One in three Registered Nurses [in Indiana] is an alum. More than 90% of its nursing graduates choose to remain in Indiana, working in hospitals and care settings,” he adds.
The last witness, Jasmine L. Travers, assistant professor at New York University’s College of Nursing, concisely summed up how to fix the nursing shortage. She suggested: “To improve access to and quality of long-term are, we must ensure that all direct care workers receive a living wage, a safe, respectful work environment, opportunities for advancement, adequate training, and accessible benefits to maintain their health and well-being. Only when we recognize that these workers are critically important, hardworking processionals, can we begin to improve equity and health outcomes for staff and patients alike.”
Spotlight on shortages
According to John E. Gage, MBA, NHA, President & CEO, of the Rhode Island Health Care Association (RIHCA), the Covid-19 pandemic had a dramatic impact on the healthcare sector across the country and especially in Rhode Island, and a disproportionate impact on nursing facilities. On a national level, in February 2020 nursing facilities workforce totaled 1,587,000. Today, it is 1,462,800, down by 124,200 or 7.8%. In Rhode Island, it is more dramatic. Pre-pandemic RI nursing facility workforce was 9,797 (2/2020). Current BLS data shows the most recent number of workers in RI nursing facilities is 8,300 – down 1,497 workers or 15.3%. This is just about double the rate of loss of workers post-pandemic in RI compared to the national statistics.