REPUBLICANS IMPERVIOUS TO SCIENCE, SELF-INTEREST
In December, I argued that the coronavirus vaccination campaign would be a test of who had the upper hand in the United States: the geniuses (not all of them American) who invented and produced these safe and effective vaccines in record time or the conspiratorial crackpots who believe internet rumors that vaccines are unsafe and unnecessary. More than six months later, it’s evident that the forces of ignorance and irrationality are so strongly entrenched that no amount of scientific evidence and public exhortation will sway them.
The United States missed President Joe Biden’s target for administering a vaccination shot to 70% of adults by July 4. Only 67% of adults have received at least one dose.
The problem is that a significant percentage of the country refuses to get vaccinated. While young people and African Americans exhibit vaccine hesitancy, the most problematic group by far is Republicans. According to a new Post-ABC News poll, 86% of Democrats have gotten at least one vaccine shot, compared with only 45% of Republicans. Forty-seven percent of Republicans say they likely won’t get vaccinated, compared with only 6% of Democrats.
The states that have the lowest vaccination rates — Mississippi, Alabama, Arkansas, Louisiana, Wyoming — are all Republican redoubts. It’s no coincidence that many red states are also seeing the worst outbreaks of the disease in recent weeks.
Aren’t those who are not vaccinated worried about the far more transmissible delta variant? Data from Israel show that, while the Pfizer vaccine is only 64% effective in preventing delta-variant infection, it is 93% effective in preventing hospitalization. That’s still a powerful argument for vaccination. But 57% of Republicans in the Post-ABC poll say officials are exaggerating the delta variant’s risk, compared with only 12% of Democrats. These Republicans have fallen victim to a virulent strain of misinformation circulating in the rightwing echo chamber.
Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene, R-Ga., of “Jewish space lasers” fame, tweeted on June 22, based on outdated guidance, that “The WHO says ‘children should not be vaccinated.’” (The World Health Organization actually says “that the Pfizer/BioNTech vaccine is suitable for use by people aged 12 years and above.”)
On July 3, Rep. Thomas Massie, R-Ky., tweeted: “I’ve been contacted by members of our voluntary military who say they will quit if the COVID vaccine is mandated. I introduced HR 3860 to prohibit any mandatory requirement that a member of the Armed Forces receive a vaccination against COVID-19.” Numerous veterans pointed out that military members can’t simply “quit” — that would be going AWOL — and that they already receive numerous mandatory vaccinations.
When Fox’s top-rated bloviator Tucker Carlson is not busy fearmongering about immigration, he is fearmongering about vaccination. He has repeatedly claimed, for example, that the administration’s own data “show a massive increase in deaths” from coronavirus vaccines. Not quite. He is citing uncorroborated reports that can be submitted by anyone. These raw numbers include people who died in a car accident or committed suicide after being vaccinated. Naturally, Carlson won’t say if he has been vaccinated himself. He is fearmongering for both profit and political advantage.
Sadly, roughly one-third of the country is impervious to science and even self-interest. That’s a big problem for the rational rest. Widespread vaccine resistance ensures that COVID-19 will continue circulating as more virulent strains emerge. The only way we are likely to achieve “herd immunity” now is the hard way — by having a lot more people fall ill and die from the delta variant. The anti-vaxxers have a lot to answer for.