Chattanooga Times Free Press

Has TV replaced the movies for good?

- BY KEVIN MCDONOUGH Contact Kevin McDonough at kevin .tvguy@gmail.com.

When did television eclipse the movies as the more thoughtful and influentia­l medium? Many would argue that the arrival of “The Sopranos” in 1999 ushered in a peak TV era in which shows from “Breaking Bad” to “The Wire” became more talked-about than the average film.

The rise of streaming television after “House of Cards” arrived on Netflix in 2013 only accelerate­d this trend. Except for the so-called Oscar season touting “important” movies that quickly vanish from screens (and memory), for many grownups the moviegoing experience has become kid stuff, a dismissibl­e jumble of franchises, sequels and comic book-inspired “tentpole” distractio­ns.

Curiously, this isn’t the first time this has happened. When television moved from a novelty to the norm in the early 1950s, movie attendance plummeted. Studios reacted as corporatio­ns often do — with terror.

Studios refused to create product for the small screen, hoping to “starve” it of content until audiences came to their senses.

As a result, dramas made for television often came out of the New York theater world, far from Hollywood. And while “stagey” by big-screen standards, they featured some of the best actors, directors and writers then working.

As a result, some of the most acclaimed movies to come out of the 1950s were merely remakes of teleplays that had already aired. Writer Paddy Chayefsky and star Ernest Borgnine would win Oscars for the 1955 drama “Marty” (8 p.m., TCM, TV-PG), about a lovelorn Bronx butcher adapted from a 1953 “Philco Television Playhouse” production.

Other TV originals including “Days of Wine and Roses” and “Twelve Angry Men” would inspire highly respected movie adaptation­s. Early TV was an incubator for writing and directing talent, including Chayefsky, Woody Allen, Mel Brooks, Sidney Lumet, Neil Simon and John Frankenhei­mer, among others, who would influence Hollywood for decades.

By the end of the 1950s the studios cried uncle and began producing fare for TV networks, flooding the airwaves with cowboy and detective shows that crowded out the more urbane fare. Writers like Rod Serling (“The Twilight Zone”) and Gene Rodenberry (“Star Trek”) continued to carry the torch for

thoughtful scripts. But in many ways, TV became dumber and more disposable as it became more popular.

It wasn’t until the end of the 20th century that TV regained its status as the smarter and more influentia­l medium.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States