HISTORIC HOSPITAL AWAITS DEMOLITION
Catholic system that runs Franciscan Health Hammond closed Franciscan St. James Health in Chicago Heights in 2018, also citing low demand for inpatient care even as nonprofit chain has built new hospitals in wealthier suburbs
In 1898, three nuns took a train to the south shore of Lake Michigan to start a hospital.
They converted an old farmhouse in Hammond to a seven-bed medical center. They treated their first patient for a broken leg amid carpenters hammering nails. Surgeons laid their patients on a kitchen table for operations.
The hospital — then named after St. Margaret, known for her service to the poor — eventually became one of the largest in the area. Hundreds of thousands of Indiana and Illinois residents took their first, or last, breaths there.
One hundred and 24 years later, the hospital has, in a sense, come full circle. This spring, Franciscan Alliance, the nonprofit owner — which is still affiliated with the same Catholic order of sisters — plans to demolish most of the 226bed Franciscan Health Hammond complex, leaving only eight beds, an emergency department and outpatient services. The move cost 83 jobs at the hospital and 110 more at a long-term, acute-care center that rented space there.
The news stung many in this city of nearly 80,000 people, who have watched businesses and neighbors flee Hammond for decades.
It’s especially painful, they say, because the hospital system has dedicated more than a half billion dollars in recent years to new facilities in wealthier, less-diverse communities.
“It’s deplorable that a Catholic institution like the Franciscans would make a financially motivated decision and leave thousands of people potentially at risk,” said Mayor Thomas McDermott Jr., who says he was informed of the downsizing only two hours before it was announced. “I’m not trying to be alarmist, but people are gonna die because of this decision. And they know it.”
But the larger question is whether Hammond needs a hospital with hundreds of beds, given the shifts in medical practice and transportation in the 21st century. Only 50 to 60 of its beds are full on most days, said Patrick Maloney, the hospital’s chief executive officer. Another Franciscan Alliance hospital is only six miles away. Much more care today is being delivered on an outpa
tient or virtual basis than even five years ago.
And the Hammond hospital has had quality concerns. It rates only one out of five stars on Medicare.gov, the lowest possible score and worst of any of the nine rated hospitals in Lake County, Indiana.
“Stewardship of our resources is one of the components of our Catholic mission,” Maloney said via email. “Key to that is efficient delivery of care.”
He said Franciscan is investing $45 million to transform the campus and will continue to operate a medical clinic there for uninsured or underinsured patients, as well as offering services including imaging, a medical lab and prenatal care.
While rural hospital closings often get more attention, cities like Hammond also have been prone to losing medical services, as health systems adjust to changes in care and opt to invest in places where more people have private insurance. But the shutdowns raise questions about the changing mission of nonprofit hospitals — and whom they help.
Since the 1930s, the urban hospitals most likely to close are those serving low-income, minority populations, according to research by Alan Sager, a professor at Boston University’s School of Public Health. He calls large swaths of Detroit and New York City “medical wastelands.”
When the city hospital in Hartford, Connecticut, contracted in the 1970s, it kept its emergency room running — until that got too expensive, Sager said.
“I predict, within a decade, despite the best intentions of everyone involved, it will prove financially unsustainable to support an eight-bed hospital plus ER in Hammond,” he said.
Hammond’s population is down about a third from its peak, in the mid-20th century. Like other former manufacturing hubs in the Midwest and Northeast, the city has been hollowed out by deindustrialization and white flight to suburban areas. It’s in the part of Indiana affectionately known as “the Region” that’s essentially an extension of Chicago’s South Side, crisscrossed with freight train tracks, dissected by interstates and littered with factories in varying states of decay.
On a recent morning, Franciscan Health Hammond’s parking garage and surrounding lots were mostly empty. A sprinkling of people trickled out of the hospital. A sign advised that birthing services had moved to the suburbs.
The ZIP code that covers the hospital and its surrounding neighborhood has a poverty rate of 36%, with a median household income of $30,400. Its population is 82% Black or Latino. The hospital treats a large share of patients on Medicaid, the government insurance program for low-income people, which typically pays health care providers a lower rate than Medicare or private insurance.
For Franciscan Alliance, the driving factors in shrinking Franciscan Health Hammond were the costs required to maintain its aging infrastructure and the decline in demand for care that’s expected in that area, Maloney said.
He said Hammond residents are welcome at Franciscan Alliance’s hospital six miles away in Munster. The organization has spent at least $133 million in recent years on that facility, located in a wealthier suburb and only blocks from a larger, competing hospital.
Carlotta Blake-King, a Hammond school board trustee, said that’s not close enough, especially since the area doesn’t have much mass transit.
“I’m a senior citizen. I don’t like to drive,” she said. “Everybody can’t afford a car.”
Free transportation to medical appointments, though, is offered through Medicaid and the local township.
Franciscan Alliance has replaced older hospitals in other Indiana communities, albeit a few miles from their original locations, spending $333 million on a new medical center in Crown Point and $243 million in Michigan City.
In 2018, though, it shut down Franciscan St. James Health, a century-old facility formerly known as St. James Hospital, in Chicago Heights, a working-class suburb demographically similar to Hammond.
The missions of many nonprofit hospital chains like Franciscan Alliance have evolved. Around the turn of the 20th century, hospitals often deliberately set up shop in lowerincome neighborhoods, with community members providing time, money and supplies. When St. Margaret opened, for example, local farmers donated food. The Internal Revenue Service exempted these, as so-called charity hospitals, from paying taxes.
Today, “Hospitals are operating as corporations, as moneymaking business entities, and their decisions are largely driven by financial concerns,” said Ge Bai, a professor of accounting and health policy at Johns Hopkins University. “The line between the current nonprofit hospitals and for-profit hospitals is very, very murky.”
In 2018, nonprofit hospitals provided less unreimbursed Medicaid and charity care than their forprofit counterparts, Bai’s research found. But she noted that Franciscan Alliance spent more than the average nonprofit on both fronts.
Pat Vosti, a retired nurse from Hammond, worked in the hospital’s cardiology unit, so she knows time is of the essence in health care. She’s concerned about patients who have to be diverted to other hospitals.
“It’s a matter of minutes, but minutes count in some instances, you know?” she said.
But people have been bypassing the Hammond hospital for years. Along with its sister campus in Dyer, it has only a 15% market share, according to a 2016 bond filing, compared with 45% for Franciscan’s Michigan City facility and 38% for Crown Point.
“Now, why they haven’t been using it could be a function of management choices made 15, 20 years ago: ‘Don’t build that new ER, don’t recruit those young doctors, don’t open a service for substance abuse,’ ” said Nancy Kane, an adjunct professor at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health. “This is usually a gradual death. These places don’t suddenly go bad.”
“I’M A SENIOR CITIZEN. I DON’T LIKE TO DRIVE. EVERYBODY CAN’T AFFORD A CAR.” CARLOTTA BLAKE-KING, Hammond school board trustee
“IT’S DEPLORABLE THAT A CATHOLIC INSTITUTION LIKE THE FRANCISCANS WOULD MAKE A FINANCIALLY MOTIVATED DECISION AND LEAVE THOUSANDS OF PEOPLE POTENTIALLY AT RISK.” THOMAS MCDERMOTT JR., mayor of Hammond