Chicago Sun-Times

Cusack plays nicely nasty in a solid Old West fable

- BY RICHARD ROEPER, MOVIE COLUMNIST rroeper@suntimes.com | @RichardERo­eper

It ain’t easy being an Irish carpenter/undertaker in a muddy frontier town in the mid-19th century. Sure, you’ve got a beautiful and strong and smart French wife, and two lovely children, with another one on the way — but you’re struggling to make ends meet, and you’ve just had to put down your only working horse, and now there’s got a posse of nefarious, gun-toting creeps showing up in the middle of the night, making demands and throwing around threats.

And that’s just a Tuesday.

Emile Hirsch is the carpenter Patrick Tate, and Deborah Francois is his wife Audrey — and just when they were talking about maybe leaving the town of Garlow, business starts picking up for Patrick.

Which is kind of a classic good news/bad news scenario, what with Patrick being an undertaker and all.

Writer-director Ivan Kavanagh’s “Never Grow Old” is a dark and spare and bloodspatt­ered Western, with fine work from Hirsch and Francois, and an entertaini­ngly nasty turn by John Cusack as the villain.

The Garlow of 1849 is a repressed but peaceful little town run by the fire-and-brimstone Preacher Pike (Danny Webb), who has banished all traces of alcohol, gambling and “whores.”

Enter Cusack’s Dutch, one of those eloquent killers who love to listen to the sound of their own voice. He also clearly relishes the unsettling, menacing effect his mere presence creates. So when Dutch learns of the town’s dry profile and sanctimoni­ous ways, he decides he’s going to stick around

and facilitate some major changes.

Cut to a month later, with booze flowing in the re-opened and packed saloon.

Garlow is also suffering from a rash of violence that usually ends with one or more bodies in pools of blood, creating more and more work for Patrick the carpenter/undertaker.

A town that not long ago aspired to be a kind of heaven has turned into hell on Earth.

Hirsch‘s Irish accent comes and goes from one line reading to the next, but he’s solid as the conflicted Patrick, who as an Irish Catholic was never fully accepted by Preacher Pike and his flock, and now seems to be almost enjoying his status as one of the few people in town Dutch seems to respect. (Dutch even formally asks Patrick to be his friend, in a kind of bro-proposal.)

Cusack delivers suitably chilling work as the murderous Dutch, who pulls the trigger with matter-of-fact precision and almost always finds a way to justify his actions.

Writer-director Kavanagh serves up the religious imagery and allegories in heaping portions, sometimes to the point of using visual exclamatio­n points to punctuate already obvious points. Still, this is a wellmade, rough-edged and solid frontier fable with a distinctiv­e look and fine performanc­es all around.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States