2013 | 11-5 | Lost divisional round

Pagano’s path: The Colts’ second year under Pagano meant continuity in the 3-4 and his aggressive, blitzing style. But after giving up 44 points in a playoff win over the Chiefs and 43 in a season-ending loss to the Patriots, questions festered about the defense’s consistency, athleticism and supply of playmakers. Mathis was outstanding, as usual, with 19½ sacks. And inside linebacker Jerrell Freeman had a breakout season with 5½ sacks and six forced fumbles. Vontae Davis showed potential as a shutdown corner but was still a focal point for the consistency questions.

Quote of note: “It’s not the level of play any of those guys or the coaches expect.”

— Pagano after the Colts surrendered 234 yards and six touchdowns on the ground in the playoff loss to the Patriots