Inflation, deflation and ‘collapse’ bunk
Western media’s alternating narratives about the risks facing China’s economy all fall flat
During the year, some Western media outlets have attributed global inflation and deflation risk to China. More recently, the claim has been that China’s economy is about to collapse. In reality, China’s economic recovery will intensify in the current half of this year.
Information war is the new normal in international media. Contrarian voices are not just marginalized, but algorithm excluded. Also, the line between ideologies and facts has blurred. The New York Times columnist Bret Stephens believes China’s economy is on secular decline (Aug 29), just as he denies climate change and promotes neoconservative foreign policy.
The interest conflicts of some “opinion leaders” are obvious. The Hill’s Peter St Onge, who declared that China has collapsed (Sep 13), is a fellow of the Heritage Foundation, a neoconservative think tank. Bloomberg interviewed a purported China expert named Kyle Bass, who said “China’s economy is “circling the drain” (Sep 11). Bass is a Texasbased investor and a member of several anti-China groups who has for years (unsuccessfully) used his hedge fund to bet against China and the yuan. His alleged stock manipulation has been scrutinized by US regulators and The Wall Street Journal.
Then there was the bizarre Newsweek story (Sept 5), suggesting Shanghai “has turned into a ‘ghost town’” due to China’s economic collapse. It built on a tweet by “independent journalist” Michael Yon, who cites a mystery “friend from China” to back up the claim.
Yon is a former member of “Special Forces” who reportedly spent more time “embedded with combat units” than any other journalist in Iraq and has popped up in destabilized targets ever since, including Hong Kong in 2019. In the past, his credibility has been challenged by US media and even the Pentagon.
In the past three quarters, the three media myths about China risks have been inflation, deflation and collapse. But what are the facts?
When China withdrew the COVID-19 prevention and control measures and began reopening its economy at the beginning of this year, international observers warned that the world’s second-largest economy would become a “global inflation threat”. There was a problem with the narrative. Numbers did not back it up, as I showed in an op-ed in China Daily in March.
After the first quarter of the year passed, international pundits turned their earlier narrative upside down. When Chinese inflation rate was flat in June, these oracles claimed China was facing an impending deflationary crash.
But was China really a global deflation risk? That presumes that price levels in China reflect a sustained fall, and that such deflation is somehow exported worldwide.
In reality, the deflationary preconditions were not in place, as I showed in an op-ed in July. Then, I predicted that despite international headwinds, China’s “rebound is strengthening … and economic recovery is likely to strengthen in the second half of the year”.
Now that seems to be the case. The better-than-expected economic data for August suggests that China’s economic recovery is strengthening. On the supply side, the industrial value added recorded a 4.5 percent year-on-year increase. On the demand side, retail sales, a main gauge of consumption, beat expectations following the summer travel peak and consumption-boosting measures.
In the coming quarters, the rebound is likely to further strengthen on stimulus, including the increase in tax allowances. And early signs suggest that consumption recovery will accelerate during the upcoming National Day holidays.
The key issue for domestic recovery remains the ailing property market, though policymakers hope to restore consumer confidence in the sector through a reduced down payment ratio and a ceiling on new mortgage rates.
As recovery gathers pace in firsttier cities, policymakers hope to see positive spillover effects in other cities and regions. On Sept 15, the People’s Bank of China, the country’s central bank, kept the interest rate unchanged but boosted liquidity through medium-term lending. Moreover, the sharp, geopolitically-induced downturn in semiconductors may be bottoming out. And Huawei’s impressive 5G Mate 60 suggests China is moving toward self-sufficiency in high-tech much faster than expected.
The challenging external headwinds reflect some moderation, for now. As long as the West’s geopolitical unilateralism and protectionism continue, global demand is likely to remain sluggish, weighing heavily on global recovery.
The eurozone is coping with recession, the United Kingdom is struggling under the disastrous impact of Brexit, the US economy is flirting with recessionary risks, and Japan’s rising debt continues to maintain persistent stagnation and deflation. In contrast, China’s growth could be anything between 4.5 percent and 5 percent this year. Given the US trade wars against and its geopolitical targeting of China, it would be an impressive achievement.