AP Top 25 Reality Check: Fallout from rare Alabama loss
Alabama loses so infrequently it seems to shift the shape of the season when it happens.
The Crimson Tide took an L on Saturday at Tennessee that pushed the Volunteers to No. 3 in the AP Top 25 presented by Regions Bank. The Vols received 15 first-place votes, the most they have gotten since 1999.
After falling on a field goal as time expired, the Crimson Tide slipped three spots to No. 6, snapping a streak of 40 straight polls in the top five. Alabama is the highest ranked team that has lost.
The Tide has won a couple of games decided in the final seconds this season before letting one get away so it’s understandable some AP voters — and fans — are seeing a trend that could lead to more losses.
But Alabama has only lost multiple regular-season games (excluding conference championships) in a season twice (2010 and 2019) since 2008.
Maybe even more impressive is just how difficult it has been to put the Tide away in the regular season. In 13 regular-season losses over that span, the average margin has been 5.4 points.
There have been two double-digit losses, none by more than 14, and three on walk-off field goals, including the last two.
Reality Check cautions against making any grand proclamations about the Alabama dynasty’s long-term health and is fine with the Tide’s short fall.
No. 1 Georgia (7-0)
Next: vs. Florida, Oct. 29 in Jacksonville, Florida.
Reality check: Been a quiet couple of weeks for TE Brock Bowers (six catches for 51 yards). Expect that to change as the games get more challenging down the stretch.
Ranked: Just right.
No. 2 Ohio State (6-0) Next: vs. Iowa, Saturday.
Reality check: C.J. Stroud has relinquished Heisman front-runner status (for whatever that’s worth in October) to Tennessee’s Hendon Hooker, but plenty of time and bigger challenges are left for the Buckeyes’ quarterback.
Ranked: Too high.
No. 3 Tennessee (6-0) Next: vs. Tennessee-Martin, Saturday.
Reality check: The Vols’ offensive style, up-tempo and lots of explosive plays, puts extra pressure on its defense. It’s vulnerable, but holds up well against the run (2.93 yards per carry against) and won’t face many more opponents built to exploit the weaknesses. Ranked: Should be 2. No. 4 Michigan (7-0) Next: vs. Michigan State, Oct. 29.
Reality check: Wolverines offensive line is gunning for a second straight Joe Moore Award, led by Virginia transfer C Olu Oluwatimi.
Ranked: Good case for the Wolverines to be ahead of the Buckeyes.
No. 5 Clemson (7-0) Next: vs. No. 14 Syracuse, Saturday.
Reality check: Tigers have yet to get the running game cranking, but RB Will Shipley had his best game (120 yards on 20 carries) this season against a Power Five opponent vs. Florida State.
Ranked: Just right.
No. 6 Alabama (6-1) Next: vs. No. 24 Mississippi State, Saturday.
Reality check: Penalties (9.4 per game, 129th in the nation) and turnovers (minus-5 margin) hurt. The Tide has been sloppy but has also outgained its opponent in each game. Ranked: Just right.
No. 7 Mississippi (7-0) Next: at LSU, Saturday. Reality check: Can the Rebels’ spectacular and versatile running game — three 100-yard rushers against Auburn — keep them unbeaten until Alabama comes to Oxford on Nov. 12?
Ranked: Little high.
No. 8 TCU (6-0)
Next: vs. No. 17 Kansas State, Saturday.
Reality check: Horned Frogs get a fourth straight ranked opponent and each
game has gotten increasingly difficult. Can they keep up the intensity? Ranked: Little low.
No. 9 UCLA (6-0)
Next: at No. 10 Oregon, Saturday.
Reality check: Duke transfer WR Jake Bobo (five touchdowns and 16 yards per catch) has been one of the best portal additions in the Pac-12.
Ranked: Feels high, but we’ll know for sure this week.
No. 10 Oregon (5-1)
Next: vs. No. 9 UCLA, Saturday.
Reality check: Since allowing 9.2 yards per play to Georgia, the Ducks have held their next five opponents below 6.0. That’s a long way from dominant, but solid.
Ranked: About right. No. 11 Oklahoma State (5-1)
Next: vs. No. 20 Texas, Saturday.
Reality check: QB Spencer Sanders got off to a promising start this season, but has completed fewer than half his passes in the last two games.
Ranked: Too high.