Taylor Swift and the Republican love affair with conspiracy theories
Several years ago, Taylor
Swift was far from the femme fatale some members of the MAGA far right now consider her to be.
Many conservatives used to revere Swift. In 2015, Republican lawmakers invited the pop icon for personal tours of the U.S. Capitol and offered to provide donors tickets to her concerts. Even Donald Trump stated she was “terrific” and “fantastic.”
How times have changed. Swift is now political poison to the right, largely despised for her progressive viewpoints, her unabashed support of feminism and, perhaps worst of all, for having the gall to inject herself into the NFL.
“The NFL is totally RIGGED for the Kansas City Chiefs, Taylor Swift, and Mr. Pfizer [Travis Kelce],” charged Mike Crispi, a Salem Radio talk show host, “all to spread DEMOCRAT PROPAGANDA.” On Fox News, Jesse Watters accused Swift of being a “Pentagon asset.” Newsmax host Greg Kelly accused Swift fans of idolatry: “If you look it up in the Bible, it’s a sin.” One America News host Alison Steinberg suggested Swift and Kelce were plotting to brainwash teenagers into thinking about sports when their focus should be on Jesus Christ. And on and on and on.
The NFL has been a historically conservative organization with a right-leaning fan base. Taylor Swift represents assertive, powerful, independent womanhood. She is pro-choice and a staunch advocate of LGBTQIA rights, and she openly espouses and supports liberal and progressive positions on race, gender, class and economics. Hence, she epitomizes most of the things despised by many conservatives, especially by the reactionary right, and they view her as a credible and serious threat.
The reality is that for many decades, conspiracy theories have been a fundamental factor of right-wing politics. During the McCarthy era of the 1950s, the modern right feared that communists had infiltrated virtually all avenues of American society. During the 1960s, Republicans decried the civil rights and antiwar movements as being engineered and agitated by Russian politicians in Moscow.
Similar political paranoia was evident in the 1970s when farright strategists declared that Democrats were conspiring with leftist radicals and homosexual sympathizers to eradicate America and Christianity. In fact, such efforts were so effective that they convinced millions of Christian evangelical voters to join the Republican Party. By the 1980s, President Ronald Reagan revisited 1950s paranoia when he insisted the anti-nuclear weapons movement was a creation of the Russians, despite denials from the FBI.
What really rankles the psyches of today’s conservatives is that unlike many entertainers, Swift has demonstrated courage while being unapologetic about her convictions. She has spoken her truth despite physical threats and the potential public backlash. She has refused to remain silent, even if that means being targeted by the menacing and sinister hostility of Trump and his MAGA sycophants.
Although she hasn’t even endorsed President Joe Biden for reelection yet, that hasn’t stopped members of MAGA power circles from threatening to declare — as one source close to Trump called it — a “holy war” on the pop megastar, especially if she ends up publicly backing the Democrats in the 2024 election.
Hostility aside, declaring war against Taylor Swift is an ill-advised tactic that could further augment her already powerful brand. She has demonstrated over and over that her cultural influence is a formidable and undeniable reality. To target someone with her profile and her legion of diehard fans is an almost futile effort that would alienate sizable segments of the county. She is simply a force to be reckoned with.