Daily Local News (West Chester, PA)

Anonymous sources matter; democracy depends on it

- Steve and Cokie Roberts

President Trump has one response to the cascade of news stories connecting his aides and advisers to Russian interests. Instead of rebutting the reports, he attacks the journalist­s who produce them.

“Many of the leaks coming out of the White House are fabricated lies made up by the #FakeNews media,” he tweeted.

“Whenever you see the words ‘sources say’ in the fake news media, and they don’t mention names, it is very possible that those sources don’t exist but are made up by fake news writers. #FakeNews is the enemy!”

Candidate Trump frequently branded the media as the “enemy.” But this is different. This is the president of the United States accusing journalist­s of fundamenta­l dishonesty, of using sources that “don’t exist” to peddle “fabricated lies.”

He offers no evidence to support his incendiary charges because there is none. The chief source of “fabricated lies” is not the news media. It is the president himself.

Trump’s assaults on the press fit a much larger and deeply dangerous pattern.

This president tries to undermine any independen­t bastion of authority and informatio­n — federal judges, FBI investigat­ors, intelligen­ce agencies — that contradict his distorted and deluded view of the world.

And those sources are fighting back, providing the leaks that Trump finds so maddening. “These are not people who pull us aside because they want to screw Donald Trump,” New York Times editor Dean Baquet told CNN. “These are people who are worried about the direction of government.”

The president has almost 30 million followers on Twitter. In effect, he controls his own broadcast network that can disseminat­e his views directly to his supporters without questions or scrutiny from independen­t journalist­s.

Trump has a well-documented history of using social media platforms to advance his “fabricated lies.” As a result, the press is completely justified in pursuing a policy of relentless skepticism toward the White House.

A major risk for journalism is the one highlighte­d by Trump’s tweets: the use of anonymous sources. As the Society of Profession­al Journalist­s states: “Anonymous sources are sometimes the only key to unlocking that big story, throwing back the curtain on corruption, fulfilling the journalist­ic missions of watchdog on the government and informant to the citizens.

But sometimes, anonymous sources are the road to the ethical swamp.”

Trump is wildly hypocritic­al, since he often invokes anonymous sources to support his own shaky allegation­s, but still, the “ethical swamp” is a real threat.

That’s why anonymous sources should be used rarely: only when the story is vital to the public interest and the informatio­n cannot be obtained in any other way.

Moreover, all good journalist­s make sure their sources know what they’re talking about. And they try to describe those informants and say why they should be trusted.

The Washington Post, for example, in a recent account of the feud between Trump and former FBI Director James Comey, explained their story was based on “the private accounts of more than 30 officials at the White House, the Justice department, the FBI and Capitol Hill, as well as Trump confidants and other senior Republican­s.”

That’s good journalism. That’s what the public needs to know. That’s why Trump’s accusation­s are so unfounded.

Anonymous sources, used carefully and explained transparen­tly, are vital to the media’s job of holding the president accountabl­e.

A healthy democracy depends on them.

 ??  ?? Cokie and Steve Roberts Columnists
Cokie and Steve Roberts Columnists

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States