Daily Local News (West Chester, PA)

‘Bad Roads,’ Ukraine’s Oscar entry, is a grim dispatch from Russian-occupied Donbas region

- By Justin Chang

The four tales told in “Bad Roads,” Natalya Volorzhbit’s bleak and unnerving first feature, add up to a startlingl­y grim panorama of life during wartime. We are in the battle-scarred Donbas region of eastern Ukraine, sometime after the spring of 2014, when tensions between Ukrainian government forces and Russian-backed separatist­s flared into armed conflict, but long before the terrible escalation­s of the last few months. Like Sergei Loznitsa’s recently rereleased “Donbass,” though less sprawling in scope and more intimate in feel, this omnibus work functions as both a lament and a prophecy. With each story, Volorzhbit pulls us a little deeper into the heart of contested, occupied territory, where soldiers and civilians dwell in unbearable tension, women are grievously exploited and, as the title suggests, wrong turns and ill-advised journeys abound.

The first unlucky traveler we meet is a middle-aged school principal (Igor Koltovskyy) driving through a security checkpoint. It’s a routine trek that quickly goes south when he can’t find his passport; his mild inebriatio­n doesn’t help his case. As he pleads with two armed soldiers (Andrey Lelyukh and Vladimir Gurin), you fear, not for the last time in this movie, that impatience will tilt into aggression and violence. But Volorzhbit has a gift for building tension through narrative restraint and mordant humor; she also has a keen sense of misdirecti­on. What gives the story its moral sting is the moment the principal recognizes — or thinks he recognizes — a young woman in a soldier’s nearby bunker, the latest living casualty of a war without end.

Does the principal really see what he thinks he sees? “Bad Roads,” which was Ukraine’s recent Oscar submission for internatio­nal feature, suggests the question is irrelevant: Whatever’s happening in this particular instance, it speaks to the long-term trauma of an ongoing military presence and the malevolenc­e that can seep, without warning, into everyday encounters. This first story, which takes place under a hot sun and centers on three men, is both a prologue and a bit of an anomaly: It establishe­s a theme — the plight of women in wartime — that will be given more unflinchin­g attention in the next three vignettes, each of which focuses on a woman’s experience and unfolds under cover of darkness.

Those stories are all self-enclosed, with conversant themes and beats but no overlappin­g characters. It’s a structural choice that underscore­s each character’s sense of isolation, but it also highlights the weird, sometimes terrible intimacy that can take root between strangers. The second story, focuses on a trio of teenage girls waiting at a bus stop for their boyfriends, who turn out to be enemy soldiers. We never meet those men, but their presence is felt in scraps of gossip that reveal the desperate, transactio­nal nature of relationsh­ips in a place where everything — a cigarette, a bag of seeds, a woman’s body — has a price. As nighttime shadows descend, the camera lingers on one of the girls (Anna Zhurakovsk­aya) as she has a lonely nighttime meeting with her grandmothe­r (Yuliya Matrosova), who begs her to come home with her, invoking memories of happier, less fraught times.

The understate­d, openair melancholy of the second story devolves into horrific, claustroph­obic violence in the third, which follows a female journalist (Maryna Klimova) as she’s imprisoned and verbally and physically abused by a soldier (Yuri Kulinich) in an undergroun­d bunker. The actors’ commitment to this brutal spectacle is remarkable, especially Klimova’s as her character tries, with as much sober determinat­ion as she can muster, to appeal to her captor’s long-abandoned sense of decency. But Volorzhbit’s technical virtuosity — the starkness of the production design, the intricate pools of light and shadow at play in her carefully composed frames and the soundtrack’s relentless “Stalker”-esque drip-drip of water — serves only to emphasize the artificial­ity of this longest and most punishing episode. (It runs about 40 minutes and seems to go on for hours, which is surely by design.)

The two middle stories in particular are marked by a certain staginess, a sense of visual abstractio­n, that points to the movie’s origins in Volorzhbit’s 2017 play, also titled “Bad Roads.” More convincing­ly inhabited is the film’s fourth and finest segment, in which a young woman (Zoya Baranovska­ya) accidental­ly runs over a chicken with her car and tries to compensate its owners, a poor older couple (Oksana Voronina and Sergei Solovyov).

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States