Rare log cabin restored in Stafford County
19th-century structure served as slave quarters near Lake Mooney
STAFFORD — Historians say a recently restored log cabin that once housed enslaved African Americans in southern Stafford County is a rare find in Virginia, or anywhere in the country.
“They were never built to last hundreds of years,” said Doug Sanford, a retired professor from the University of Mary Washington’s department of historic preservation.
“This is truly a rare survivor.”
Sanford, who retired from the university in 2017, said hundreds of small slave dwellings — such as the log cabin that’s situated on a hill near the southernmost tip of Lake Mooney — were common throughout most of the South during the 18th and 19th centuries.
Sanford, whose ancestors once owned the land the cabin stands on, joined University of Maryland associate research professor Dennis Pogue and a handful of University of Mary Washington students in late 2014 as part of a countywide study by Dovetail Cultural Resource Group of Fredericksburg.
That ran until spring 2015, and its purpose was to locate any remaining slave quarters in the county, along with long-forgotten cemeteries and other sites or structures associated with slavery in Stafford.
“We realized just in that one year there were so many of these,” Sanford said. “It was such a common form of vernacular architecture. Today, what’s left is just a low, low percentage of what was there.”
He said out of the possible hundreds of slave quarters, only seven remain standing.
“The modern decline of Stafford County’s agricultural economy and the rapid pace and extent of residential and commercial development took its toll,” Sanford said.
The research team also discovered a surprisingly high level of slave ownership among white households in Stafford by combing through U.S. census reports. Sanford said in 1860 Stafford County had 60% slave ownership in that demographic. His fourth great-grandfather, Lawrence Sanford, whose 976-acre farm included the recently restored cabin, owned 20 slaves, according to Stafford’s 1820 census.
Lawrence Sanford, who was also a captain in Col. Gregory Smith’s company with the 2nd Virginia Cavalry during the War of 1812, died in 1858 and is buried just north of the cabin in the family cemetery.
He left the farm to wife Apphia, who told census takers in 1860 she owned nine slaves who lived in three separate structures on the property, which was sold four years later after her death. Over the years the property changed hands until eventually ending up under county control as part of the Lake Mooney reservoir that opened in 2016.
Pogue said the Lake Mooney cabin probably survived demolition over the years due to its proximity to the property owner’s home on the farm. He said in the 19th century it was common to erect quarters for enslaved workers away from the primary residence of the farm.
The Burgess family took ownership of the land in 1860 and later converted the cabin into a work shed, adding more years to its lifespan. Pogue said several work tables were found in the structure, and a doorway that was added to the cabin at some point had weakened the building’s structural integrity.
“It was pitched forward by 12 inches,” Pogue said. “That was a problem.”
Sanford puts the cabin at just over 170 years old, based on the types of nails used, as well as identifying saw marks and architectural methods commonly used during that period.
“It’s the late Antebellum era. It’s about 1850,” he said.
Brion Southall, the county’s parks and recreation director, said when he first took a look inside the cabin,
he knew restoration workers faced a difficult task.
“There was dirt piled up on one edge and the logs underneath that dirt had gotten insects in them that had rotted.” Southall said. “The whole building was falling over. Something needed to be done or we were going to lose it.”
Vintage Renovation and Construction of Winchester was hired to work on the 15-by-12-foot cabin and started the six-month job in July 2021. Workers disassembled much of the cabin and took the materials off-site for restoration or replacement after giving the building an inspection from the floorboards to the rooftop.
“The flooring upstairs is quite nice and appears original based on its nails,” wrote David Logan of Vintage Renovation. “It does appear the upper portion of the cabin is in good condition.”
Wooden logs of the cabin were professionally treated to weather the elements. Those that were rotted or damaged were either replaced with similar wood or pieces were fabricated in a workshop.
A new foundation was built at the original corners of the building before workers returned the cabin and reassembled it at its original site. Additional work included a new metal roof, lime daubing, siding, doors and window frames.
Although the cabin’s exterior looks impressive and inviting, the cabin and the crumbling structures that surround it are not open to the public. Southard said hikers approaching the area should be cautious due to “several hazards” the county will eventually mitigate, including piles of debris, old building materials and an old well.
James Tully, chairman of the county’s Historical Commission, hopes the cabin and other historic sites like it across the county will soon be managed by a county official.
“We’re hoping the cultural resource specialist will assist in not only the enslaved persons cottage down at Lake Mooney, but all of the cultural resources across Stafford County,” Tully said.