Israel, Gaza versions of killings near aid convoy differ

It was hours after people in the Gaza Strip had broken their daylong fast for the holy month of Ramadan, but with famine stalking the enclave under a near total Israeli siege, few felt full and many were already thinking about how to secure their families' next meals.

Hundreds of people gathered Thursday night at Kuwait square, one of two main southern entrances to Gaza City, where occasional convoys come to distribute desperately needed aid. People came from all over the city in the northern Gaza Strip. Some had been there for hours.

Even before the aid trucks carrying flour arrived about 9 p.m., carnage and chaos engulfed the square. Gaza health officials said 20 people were killed and more than 150 wounded when Israeli forces targeted the crowd.

The Israeli military blamed the bloodshed on Palestinian gunmen. Three witnesses described shelling at the scene, while a doctor who treated victims at a hospital said their wounds appeared to be consistent with artillery shells, not bullets from rifles: in other words, Israeli arms.

Mohammad Hamoudeh, a photographer and journalist in Gaza City who said he was in the square, acknowledged that he did not see any Israeli forces or the weapons that fired on the crowd, but he said that Israeli shells fired from a distance appeared to be responsible.

“The cannons and tank shells are what targeted the civilians,” he said. “I escaped by a miracle; we saw death with our eyes.”

Referring to similar bloodshed at an aid distribution Feb. 29, he said, “It was almost the same scenario as the Nabulsi incident. There were many martyrs. The scene was horrifying.”

Dr. Eid Sabbah, the head of nursing at the Kamal Adwan Hospital, said, “It wasn't gunfire. It was ammunition from heavy weaponry that cause large openings. That's obvious from the entrance and exit wounds.”

Ibrahim Al Najjar, 42, an unemployed taxi driver, said he arrived at the square about 8 p.m. and a large crowd already had gathered. An Israeli drone hovered overhead, he said. Soon, there was shelling and firing, he said, adding that “tens were killed and injured.” He saw many dead bodies. His cousin also was killed, he said.