Accused couple plead for release
Kinleys reference COVID in request
Two co-defendants in a federal probate fraud and will forgery case have requested compassionate releases from prison only a few months into their respective sentences, citing the ongoing coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic.
John W. Kinley and Marion Diane Kinley, known as Diane Kinley, have both filed motions for sentence reductions in the United States District Court for the Western Division of Arkansas.
Neither has been released as of yet.
The Kinleys were both convicted and sentenced to terms in the Federal Bureau of Prisons system last year after offering guilty pleas in the fake will case of Matthew Seth Jacobs.
Jacobs, a Camden resident, was the recipient of a multi-million dollar settlement in April 2012 as a result of injuries he sustained in the 2010
Deepwater Horizon oil rig explosion. The Kinleys became acquainted with Jacobs through Diane Kinley’s sister, Donna Herring, who federal investigators later discovered had embedded her family in Jacobs’ life after he approached her, a real estate agent, for assistance in purchasing a home and investment properties.
After Jacobs was killed in a January 2015 automobile accident at 34 years old, Herring produced the only will discovered to this date in his name; it subsequently was discovered that Herring had forged the will with the Kinleys acting as signatories.
John Kinley was sentenced to prison on Nov. 12, 2019 to 12 months and one day; he has been incarcerated at the Federal Correctional Institute in Forrest City, Ark. since Jan. 22, 2020. Diane Kinley was sentenced the following day to 18 months in prison; she has been housed at the Federal Medical Center Carswell Unit in Fort Worth, Tex. for the same period of time.
Motions denied
On April 16, both John and Diane Kinley filed motions for sentence reductions, citing the federal First Step Act, a 2018 criminal justice reform law, which provides for compassionate release under some circumstances, including terminal illness, advanced age and other “extraordinary and compelling reasons.”
John Kinley, citing the CARES (Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economic Security) Act, which provides for home confinement of prisoners for a period longer than the maximum six months laid out in the U.S. code, asked for release on the basis of multiple medical conditions, including a degenerative disk disorder, spinal stenosis, high cholesterol, anxiety, stress and acid reflux.
“Upon release, I will return home to my wife of 28 years,” a note attached to John Kinley’s motion reads. “I will also reunite with my sons, their wives and grandchildren whom I’ve greatly missed. My job at the Country Club is waiting for me. I will begin work when I return home.”
Diane Kinley, citing the same provisions of the law, asked for release on the basis of multiple medical conditions as well, including a degenerative disk disease, knee degeneration resulting from arthritis, osteo-arthritis, chronic migraines, high blood pressure, fibromyalgia, heart disease, high cholesterol and anxiety.
John and Diane Kinley noted in their motions that they requested a compassionate release from their respective prison wardens, with John Kinley indicating that he believed the requirement that 30 days pass without a response from the warden had been lifted due to the ongoing public health crisis, and Diane Kinley saying “the exercise in completing one’s Administrative Remedy would be an exercise in futility.”
Judge Susan O. Hickey, who presided over the Kinleys criminal case, denied both their motions, citing procedural problems in their filings related to not waiting for an Administrative Remedy — a compassionate release from their respective prisons’ wardens or at least 30 days between their request for one and their filing their motions in federal court.
On April 28, after 30 days had passed since both John and Diane Kinley requested release from their respective prisons’ wardens, they again filed motions in the U.S. District Court for the Western Division of Arkansas for compassionate release. John Kinley cited a death attributable to COVID-19 having occurred in the FCI in his second motion. Diane Kinley referred to the prison as a “petri dish” in her letter, referring to the high community spread of COVID-19 in congregate living settings like prisons and nursing homes.
Their motions reached the court on May 6 after traveling through the prison mail system. On May 7, Hickey appointed public defender Bruce Eddy, who represented Diane Kinley in the criminal proceedings against her last year, to represent both in any further motions filed in reference to the First Step Act.
FCI outbreak
The FCI in Forrest City has been the location of one of the largest coronavirus outbreaks in correctional facilities in Arkansas. The Arkansas Democrat-Gazette reported that at least 622 inmates and 18 staff members there had tested positive for COVID-19 as of Friday. The Democrat-Gazette also reported on May 11 that no deaths had been reported among inmates at the facility by that time; John Kinley’s second motion contradicts that.
According to the BOP website, active cases of COVID-19 have been confirmed in 52 BOP facilities and 30 Residential Reentry Management Centers, where federal prisoners may be transferred to in advance of their release to prepare for reentry into society. The website’s case tracker does not list any deaths in the prison facility at Forrest City; it also lists fewer cases than reported by the Arkansas Department of Health and Democrat-Gazette.
Other players
Donna Herring, the primary defendant in the years-long fake will case, has not requested any sort of early release as of
May 24. She is currently incarcerated at the Bryan Federal Prison Camp in Bryan, Tex. Herring was sentenced on Nov. 12, 2019 to 41 months in prison after pleading guilty in January 2019 to wire fraud.
Jordan Alexandra Peterson, another defendant in the case and Herring’s daughter, who pleaded guilty to lying to a federal investigator in relation to the case in January 2018 and was sentenced last November to three years probation, has been serving her sentence since Jan. 22.
Herring and the Kinleys have also been ordered to pay $132,964.66 in restitution to Matthew Seth Jacobs’ son Jordan Jacobs, who at the time of his father’s death was his sole descendent and the heir-at-law to his estate.
Peterson was not included in the restitution order.
In the fake will created by Herring, Peterson was named as the primary beneficiary of Matthew Seth Jacobs’ estate, with only $50,000 being “willed” to Jordan Jacobs to help him pay for college or trade school. Jordan Jacobs later received an additional settlement from his father’s life insurance of about $250,000, before the contested will was discovered to have been forged.
In addition to the restitution owed to Jordan Jacobs, Herring and the Kinleys were also ordered to return all property from the estate, property purchased with proceeds from the estate and leftover monies from the estate.