What’s the tastiest way to cut back on pet treats?

Your pal loves to gobble up treats, but you worry all the ingredients aren’t the healthiest—and those all-natural nibbles can be pretty pricey. So we asked readers for their top ways to save while giving their furry friends a healthy treat:

58% ❤ this idea!

Mix treats with lower-calorie kibble and shake in a jar, says Sue Best. The treats’ smell will permeate the jar, and he’ll think he’s getting a goodie.

42% ❤ this idea!

Dice up cantaloupe and offer it to your pet, says Claire Brown. Both cats and dogs love to eat the melon, which vets say is perfectly safe for them.