Where to stay in Key West
THE NEW
The Marker Waterfront Resort: A stone’s throw from the historic seaport and in the heart of Old Town, the Marker hotel opened in December 2014 as the first new hotel built in Key West since 1994. Owner Pritam Singh, the developer behind Truman Annex and the Key West Golf Club, has taken great care to ensure that the Marker blends seamlessly into its tropical, historic surroundings. With 96 guest rooms, a courtyard pool and Cero Bodega restaurant, it embodies Old Key West in new luxe digs. From $489 per night. 200 William; 305-501-5193.
THE NOW
NYAH: Short for Not Your Average Hotel, this wallet-friendly guesthouse is tucked away behind a charming conch cottage in Old Town. Perfect for those traveling in large groups, each of NYAH’s 36 unique rooms are bare bones and clean, and can accommodate up to six people comfortably thanks to flexible configurations. The hotel also offers a courtyard pool, complimentary continental breakfast and happy hour in a setting that couldn’t be more Key West. From $40 per person per night for groups. 420 Margaret; 305-296-9259.
THE NEXT
The Gates: Appropriately named the Gates, this is the first hotel to greet visitors who are driving from Miami as they turn onto the island from U.S. 1. The New Town hotel opened in April. While it’s a 15-minute hike to the attractions of Old Town, shuttle service will soon be provided to guests. They’re aiming to create a destination resort with island-chic rooms, a pool, cigar bar, food truck and weekly parties courting locals. Rates from $249 per night. 3824 N. Roosevelt; 305-320-0930.
THE CLASSIC
Casa Marina: Conceived by oil tycoon Henry Flagler, who built the Overseas Railroad originally connecting Key West to mainland Florida, the 311-room Casa Marina, A Waldorf Astoria Resort is a historic South Florida gem. The lavish Mediterranean Revival property situated on the Atlantic Ocean is fully updated with an elegant poolscape, private beach and waterfront dining. From $449 per night. 1500 Reynolds; 305-296-3535.