Houston Chronicle

A councilman. The youth summit. And me.

- By Sumer Zakaria Zakaria is a rising senior at St. Agnes Academy. She is passionate about journalism and interested in politics. Bookmark Gray Matters. We were told to sit quietly in back.

Loud voices collided on the other side of the closed door, where Councilman Dwight Boykins was addressing another group of students in a hotel ballroom in Westchase. My group, which had just been meeting with Mayor Sylvester Turner, was told to hang back, but some curious students leaned into the wooden door, as if holding cups to their ears, trying to make out what was going on.

One of the adults directing us told another, “He’s going to be mad if another big group walks in.”

I wondered why the councilman would be mad, since he was there to talk to us. I was one of more than 80 students who had gathered, mostly people of color from the Houston area, for the annual Youth Advocacy Summit. For me, a 17-year-old student at St. Agnes Academy, it was a chance to get insight on real-world issues and ideas on how to advocate for solutions in my own community.

The highlight of the week was meeting several candidates for local office and getting to question some running for mayor. We were waiting to question Boykins when we heard the commotion.

Finally, we were allowed to go in and told to sit quietly in back.

Tension hung heavy in the cold air. Girls glanced around anxiously. Boys sat in silence, shock and embarrassm­ent on their faces.

Boykins seemed to be trying to rectify a crude comment that had offended some students. I later learned from other students that the councilman had advised the girls to keep their “legs closed” in romantic relationsh­ips and, at one point, he had called a girl to the front, awkwardly embracing her in a way that made her feel uncomforta­ble.

Facing us, Boykins’ tone and facial expression­s seemed more defensive than apologetic. Whispers permeated the air. A group near me muttered that they wanted to respond but weren’t sure how.

Neither did I. Boykins’ inartful remark, an apparent attempt to relate to youth in the room, had backfired. The organizers of the event seemed to miss opportunit­ies to intervene. And though I thought I understood what Boykins was trying to say, his attempts to explain didn’t seem to bridge any gaps.

Suddenly, a girl sprung up, telling Boykins, “If comments have to be tailored (to be appropriat­e), there’s a problem.” Her message was clear: This was not the way to speak to students, nor was his comment responsive to the actual questions students had asked. The girl also seemed to object to the councilman’s earlier embrace of the student, telling him, “Actions speak louder than words.”

Her message was powerful, yet it seemed her emotion muffled her meaning.

Another student joined the conversati­on, telling Boykins, “You are not a woman. You will never be a woman,” which only seemed to add gasoline to the fire. Boykins offered another stuttered response.

The emotion on all sides kept Boykins and the students from hearing each other — a common problem in American discourse these days.

But more than anything, it was Boykins’ choice of words that rang in my ears: Legs closed?!

It’s not that the subject matter itself was taboo. Of course, we teenagers benefit from real world examples of how sex can complicate lives and get in the way of priorities such as education and career goals.

But it was shocking to me, in this post#MeToo era, that Boykins had delved into such a sensitive subject headfirst, apparently without much forethough­t. He oversimpli­fied the issue of premarital sex by placing moral responsibi­lity solely on the shoulders of girls. He never acknowledg­ed boys’ role in the equation.

The words seemed sexist and antiquated — completely inappropri­ate in 2019, especially for someone vying to lead the fourthlarg­est city in the nation.

No public official should shy away from discussing sensitive issues with young people. The risks of unsafe sex and promiscuit­y are real, and many of us can benefit from the older generation’s personal experience­s. But there’s an appropriat­e way to address those issues: sans casting blame; without degrading youth, particular­ly women; and with respect.

Students should not be responsibl­e for teaching elected officials how to talk about sensitive topics.

Last week, I contacted Boykins to get his take on the incident. He declined comment, wishing me luck in my studies but saying he wanted attention to the episode to “die down.”

That’s understand­able. But I hope he, as a public official setting an example for Houston’s youth, understand­s that those comments sent the wrong message.

He didn’t get far trying to be cool and off-the-cuff. Kids aren’t so different from adults: Respect goes a long way.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States