G-7 expects usual Trump dissension
WASHINGTON — After they wooed him in Taormina, Italy, in 2017, President Donald Trump snubbed world leaders by dropping out of the Paris climate accords.
When they reached consensus in Charlevoix, Canada, a year later, Trump abruptly refused to sign their joint statement and escalated his trade war with personal insults.
And as the NATO allies gathered in Brussels last August, summit organizers avoided another Trumpian eruption only by prewriting the meeting’s formal policy agreement and keeping it from the American president until the last minute.
Now, as President Emmanuel Macron of France prepares to host Trump and leaders from some of the world’s leading democracies in the south of France this weekend, the United States’ closest allies have all but given up on the idea that the Group of 7 summit will produce the kind of unity and consensus about global issues that has been its hallmark for more than four decades.
“I know the points of disagreement with the U.S.,” Macron lamented to reporters Thursday as he acknowledged the group wouldn’t even try to issue its usual joint statement, known as a communiqué. “It’s pointless.”
With the world facing ominous signs of a global economic slowdown and vexing political turbulence in hot spots around the world, Trump arrives in Biarritz, France, this morning with a blunt tariff club in his hand.
That poses a challenge to America’s trading partners.
Limiting the damage
“Their operating strategy is damage limitation,” said Charles Kupchan, a professor of international affairs at Georgetown University who served on the National Security Council staff during President Barack Obama’s tenure. “The first G-7. The second G-7. The NATO summit. Trump has basically blown them all up. I’m guessing that Macron is hoping to get out of Biarritz with no blood on the floor.”
He added: “If you go in with low expectations and no communiqué, that lowers the risk of a fiasco. You have a nice chat, you have some good wine, and you go home.”
The leaders of France, Germany, Britain, Italy, Japan, Canada and the United States will meet at the beachfront resort town amid escalating alarms over the health of the global economy, which is slumping under the weight of Trump’s multifront trade wars.
In the decades after World War II, such a slowdown typically spurred American presidents to help lead a global response to prevent or mitigate recessions.
But Trump’s willingness to use tariffs as leverage over allies as well as adversaries has severely strained the relationships with other leaders.
Just days before heading to France for the summit, the president said at a rally in New Hampshire that the European Union “is worse than China, just smaller. It treats us horribly: barriers, tariffs, taxes.”
And his disdain for multilateral institutions like the United Nations, NATO and the World Trade Organization has undermined the expectation of cooperation and collaboration.
“The postwar world, which the U.S. built, was essentially one where, if there was a theme, it was: ‘Everyone benefits from everyone else’s growth,’” said Raghuram Rajan, an economist at the University of Chicago Booth School of Business, who once led India’s central bank. “It’s a positive-sum game. The idea was to help everyone grow through a rules-based system.
“What’s changed,” Rajan said, “is the view that the growth of others is actually good for the U.S. There’s much more of a zero-sum rhetoric: If they grow, it’s at my expense.”
Despite the warnings of difficult headwinds, Trump continues to insist the U.S. economy has nothing to worry about. In a tweet Friday morning, he wrote that “the Fake News Media, together with their Partner, the Democratic Party, are working overtime to convince people that we are in, or will soon be going into, a Recession.”
American officials say Trump is eager to contrast the economic success of his policies with those in slumping economies like Germany and France during a session that he called for on the global economy Sunday morning. But his fellow world leaders aren’t expected to hold back either.
Hurting world economy
“I think he will get an earful from the others,” said Peter Westmacott, a former ambassador to the United States from Britain. “There will be a sense that Trump’s trade policies are part of what is taking the world’s economy in the wrong direction.”
Trump frequently revels in other countries’ economic stumbles, casting them as competitors for a limited amount of prosperity worldwide. He has criticized the Fed, including Friday morning, for not cutting rates more aggressively to match the low rates of Europe.
But economists warn that Trump is wrong to dismiss the threat to the U.S. economy from his trade war. Trade plays a smaller role in U.S. growth than in many other rich countries, but several indicators administration officials cited last year to show a “booming” U.S. economy have all worsened, including plunging business investment and slowing factory output.
“I don’t think the U.S. can be an island of strong growth while the rest of the world is tanking,” Rajan said.Macron, as this year’s host of the G-7 gathering, isn’t counting on the United States to be a constructive part of other discussions.
He has invited several leaders from African nations to be part of sessions on the challenges facing that continent. And the leaders of India, Australia, Chile and Spain will participate in conversations about the environment, terrorism, nuclear weapons and other issues.
Anti-climate change
French officials conceded there is no hope that Trump joins the group in expressing its concern about climate change despite news that fires in the Amazon rainforests could accelerate the planet’s environmental crisis.
A few seemingly anodyne statements that diplomats from the seven countries prepared in advance will be released at the end of the summit, an EU official said, among them a document on the partnership between African nations and the G-7 countries and one on biodiversity.
For his part, Trump already has vented his frustration about France’s imposition of a tax on companies like Facebook. (He called it “foolishness” and risked insulting the G-7 host by threatening tariffs on French goods, including wine, in response.) Beyond trade, disagreements about how to contain Iran’s nuclear ambitions remain stark.
“Rather than being defined by ambition, they seem to be more about survival and just getting through it,” said Derek Chollet, executive vice president for security and defense policy at the German Marshall Fund. “They have seen the movie before. They don’t want to repeat it.”