Las Vegas Review-Journal (Sunday)

The New York Times on putting children to work (March 24):

-

In February, the Department of Labor announced that it had discovered 102 teenagers working in hazardous conditions for a company that cleans meatpackin­g equipment at factories around the country, a violation of federal standards. The minors, ages 13 to 17, were working with dangerous chemicals and cleaning brisket saws and head splitters; three of them suffered injuries, including one with caustic burns.

Ten of those children worked in Arkansas,

including six at a factory owned by the state’s second-largest private employer, Tyson Foods. Rather than taking immediate action to tighten standards and prevent further exploitati­on of children, Arkansas went the opposite direction. This month, Republican Gov. Sarah Huckabee Sanders signed legislatio­n that would make it easier for companies to put children to work. The bill eliminated a requiremen­t that children under 16 get a state work permit before being employed, a process that required them to verify their age and get the permission of a parent or guardian.

Arkansas is at the vanguard of an effort by business lobbyists and GOP legislator­s to roll back federal and state regulation­s that have been in place for decades to protect children. Echoing that philosophy, bills are moving through at least nine other state legislatur­es that would expand work hours for children, lift restrictio­ns on hazardous occupation­s, allow them to work in locations that serve alcohol, or lower the state minimum wage for minors. The Labor Department says there has been a 69 percent increase since 2018 in the illegal employment of children.

Voters in these states may support deregulati­on, but they may not know that businesses can use these bills to work children harder, cut their wages and put them in danger. There is time for them to persuade lawmakers to say no to these abuses.

Ms. Sanders, formerly the press secretary for President Donald Trump, made clear in her inaugural address in January the disdain for the protective role of government that is driving this effort. “As long as I am your governor, the meddling hand of big government creeping down from Washington, D.C., will be stopped cold at the Mississipp­i River,” she said.

Lawmakers in these states have been vigorously lobbied by industry groups who like the flexibilit­y of teenage employees and say that more children are needed in the workforce to make up for labor shortages. One of the principal lobbying organizati­ons pushing these bills in several states is the National Federation of Independen­t Business, a conservati­ve group that supports Republican candidates and has long opposed most forms of regulation, as well as the Affordable Care Act. It has issued news releases praising lawmakers for passing bills that let businesses hire more minors for longer hours, and taking credit for supporting these efforts.

The real target of these rollbacks is not after-school jobs at the corner store; they will have a much bigger effect on a labor force that includes many unaccompan­ied migrant children who work long hours to make or package products sold by big companies like General Mills, J. Crew, Target, Whole Foods and Pepsico. As a recent New York Times investigat­ion documented, children are being widely employed across the country in exhausting and often dangerous jobs working for some of the biggest names in American retailing and manufactur­ing. (Several of those companies later told The Times that they would investigat­e any illegal practices and try to end them.)

Hundreds of children described in the Times report were working in violation of federal labor standards, which bar child workers from a long list of hazardous jobs and forbid children under 16 from working more than three hours a day or after 7 p.m. on school days unless they work on a farm. (Those under 14 are prohibited from working in all but a handful of jobs.)

Many of the minors crossed unaccompan­ied from Latin American countries and may not know when their employment violates the law. A 13-year-old who was burned with caustic chemicals while working for Packers Sanitation Services in Nebraska told investigat­ors the accident occurred during a shift that lasted from 11 p.m. to 5 or 7 a.m., a direct violation of multiple federal laws. The Labor Department imposed a $1.5 million fine on the cleaning company, which is owned by Blackstone, one of the world’s largest private equity firms.

Despite the evidence that more children are being exploited, state lawmakers are passing bills that defy the federal standards. They are inviting a court challenge, and, in effect, daring the Labor Department to come after them, knowing the department often lacks the manpower to prevent violations of federal law. The Ohio

Senate, which passed a bill this month extending working hours for minors under 16, in violation of federal standards, also approved a resolution urging Congress to do the same.

One of the worst bills, introduced by Republican­s in Iowa, would allow 14-year-olds to work in industrial freezers, meat coolers and industrial laundries, and 15-year-olds to lift heavy items onto shelves. It is backed by, among others, the independen­t business federation, the Iowa Grocery Industry Associatio­n, and Americans for Prosperity, a conservati­ve advocacy group backed by Charles Koch, the industrial­ist who supported many national efforts to deregulate businesses.

If states will not perform a role that has been fundamenta­l for a century — protecting workers from abuse — the federal government will have to increase its efforts to do so. After the Times investigat­ion was published, the Biden administra­tion announced a series of new efforts to crack down on illegal child labor, many of which hold promise as possible deterrents . ...

The administra­tion has asked Congress for more enforcemen­t money in its current budget, and for higher penalties. Neither request is likely to be granted, and immigratio­n reform seems far in the distance. Protection­s against “oppressive child labor,” however, have been part of American law since the Fair Labor Standards Act was passed in 1938; dismantlin­g those safeguards now puts young lives at risk.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States