Elisha Cuthbert
She has a type! After dating hockey bad boy Sean Avery for two years, Elisha hooked up with Toronto Maple Leafs captain Dion Phaneuf in 2008. With Dion, though, she netted a keeper. The athlete, 33, and the 24 actress, 36, said “I do” in 2013, welcoming daughter Zaphire four years later. But Elisha’s still not totally comfortable with her man’s on-ice scuffles. “It is tough to watch,” she admits. “It can get a little nerve-wracking.”