Lodi News-Sentinel

Will California ever learn anything from its wildfires?

-

California that are apparently becoming the norm. Five of California's deadliest wildfires have occurred during the last two years. And six of the most destructiv­e wildfires, in terms of structures lost, occurred over the last 10 years.

Now Los Angeles County is dealing with a new fire in the Santa Clarita area that has prompted the evacuation of at least 40,000 people. And like last year, state fire resources are stretched thin as agencies fight another conflagrat­ion in Northern California and additional wildfires throughout Southern California.

It should be crystal clear by now that California needs to make major changes in the way communitie­s prepare for these inevitable blazes. The warming climate is creating conditions that fuel more devastatin­g wildfires as more and more people are moving into the wildland-urban interface, where homes and offices abut foothills, forests or other open land.

Yet lawmakers at all levels of government still refuse to fully grapple with the challenges posed by the new normal. Can we make existing homes in fire zones safer and if so, how? What responsibi­lity and obligation­s do residents in high-fire-risk areas bear for their own safety and that of their property? Are there some areas where it's too dangerous to rebuild? Why, when we know the danger and the cost, do we keep allowing new subdivisio­ns to march deeper into highfire-risk areas?

Instead, the focus has been on firefighti­ng, equipment and brush clearance. The county's post-Woolsey fire review was requested by Supervisor

Sheila Kuehl to help agencies understand what happened and how to minimize damage in future events.

The report lays out dozens of practical recommenda­tions for government agencies to better coordinate and respond to the next disaster. It's a smart exercise. County leaders are talking about a tax increase to expand the fire department.

But the report only briefly touches on the harder policy decisions that we ignore at our collective peril: "We cannot expect that all population growth in Very High or High Fire Hazard Severity areas can be protected simply by increasing resiliency to wildfire and by adding more fire engines," the report says.

Of course existing homes have to become more resilient in the face of wind-driven blazes. And California may need to invest in more firefighti­ng personnel and equipment to deal with the worsening fires.

But it is folly to think that stricter building codes and more fire engines can eliminate the danger we create by building and rebuilding in high-fire-risk areas.

Lawmakers can't necessaril­y stop people from rebuilding on land they own, given the Fifth Amendment's protection­s for property owners. But California could buy out owners to prevent them from rebuilding in highrisk areas. Cities and state agencies are talking about "managed retreat" — or relocating threatened homes — from communitie­s facing coastal erosion or flooding. Why is there not a similar policy discussion in areas that repeatedly burn?

Nor is there any serious discussion of limiting new developmen­t in high fire-risk areas. In fact, local leaders in L.A. County,

San Diego County and throughout the state are still approving massive new subdivisio­ns on hillsides in the urban fringe — exactly the areas that are most likely to burn and burn again. And for existing homes, there are few, if any, requiremen­ts for home hardening or maintenanc­e, and little assistance for homeowners who want to do it voluntaril­y.

Gov. Gavin Newsom has dismissed the idea of blocking developmen­t in fire-prone areas, saying such restrictio­ns would be counter to California's "pioneering spirit." Perhaps. But the pioneers didn't face subdivisio­ns aflame or tens of thousands of neighbors trying to evacuate at the same time.

The death and destructio­n caused by recent wildfires should have served as reminder enough that California can't keep sprawling into dangerous wildfire terrain. So far, California leaders have refused to act. What will it take?

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States