Los Angeles Times

It’s the lone live standout

-

Only one Academy Award nominee in the liveaction short film category truly merits the win.

Following a battered woman and her children’s escape from her abuser, “Just Before Losing Everything” ticks for half an hour as if it could explode at any moment. Actor Xavier Legrand’s directoria­l debut draws on a conceivabl­e scenario and booby-traps it with entirely plausible hurdles. Glimpses of the woman’s bruises and a little one’s screaming substantia­te the high stakes. Claw your armrests. Clench your teeth. This is one roller-coaster ride.

As deserving as “Just Before Losing Everything” is, you’d be best advised picking just about any of the other nominees in the office pool. They seem more likely to win.

“The Voorman Problem” comes with the star wattage of Martin Freeman (Bilbo Baggins in “The Hobbit” movies) and Tom Hollander playing, respective­ly, a psychologi­st and a prison inmate who claims to be a god. Although the film commands your attention throughout, the payoff is nil.

Unabashedl­y sappy, “Helium” milks the bond between a terminally ill child and an eccentric hospital custodian. In the end (spoiler alert!) the kid boards an imaginary blimp, presumably heaven-bound.

“Do I Have to Take Care of Everything?” takes a mildly amusing — if very slight — snapshot of a family of four cumbersome­ly tumbling out of bed, into the dining room and out onto the pavement to attend a wedding. Ha. Next.

The astonishin­gly reprehensi­ble “That Wasn’t Me” fabricates war atrocities that take place in some unspecifie­d African country for reasons it cannot articulate. It’s “Captain Phillips” stripped of facts and left with only noxious stereotype­s. Its central child soldier ultimately lives to wax poetic in front of an appreciati­ve white audience about the war crimes he committed.

— Martin Tsai “The Oscar Nominated Short Films 2014: Live Action.” No MPAA rating. Running time: 1 hour, 48 minutes. Playing: In limited release. Also on VOD.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States