Councilman describes being tased
‘I ... started shaking, almost convulsing,’ Texas official says of his police encounter.
PRAIRIE VIEW, Texas — The city councilman was kneeling on the ground when the taser struck his back, electric shocks that made him scream in pain as his muscles tensed and then went into spasms.
“I just stiffened up, started shaking, almost convulsing,” said 26-year-old Prairie View Councilman Jonathan Miller on Tuesday.
Officers arrested Miller on suspicion of interfering with a public servant and resisting arrest, then drove him to the same jail where Sandra Bland was found dead in her cell three months ago, one of several high-profile cases this year that have fueled a national debate about racial profiling and police use of force.
“I didn’t go to sleep until very early in the morning,” Miller, who is black, said of the Thursday incident. “I didn’t know what could happen.”
Miller’s arrest has outraged some of his council colleagues, who asked Mayor Frank Jackson to call a special meeting with the police chief on Thursday.
Jackson said the meeting was “premature.”
“It’s only limited information that can be shared, so it may do more harm than good,” he said.
Most of the elected officials in this historically black college town are African American, including the mayor, police chief, City Council and all but one member of the small police force.
Police Chief Larry Johnson said that it was too early to determine whether officers used excessive force in arresting Miller, but “if we made mistakes, we will correct them.”
At least one council member has demanded that police release all dashboard and body camera footage so they can judge for themselves whether Miller’s arrest was warranted. Johnson said the department had released the footage on YouTube, including body camera videos from the two officers involved and three dashboard camera videos.
“This is not a department that goes around violating people’s rights,” Johnson said outside City Hall after meeting with prosecutors. “We put all the videos out there so people can see we have nothing to hide. I welcome the scrutiny.”
Johnson said he was limited in what he could discuss because of the investigation and was not sure he would attend Thursday’s council meeting. A spokesman for the Waller County district attorney’s office said Tuesday that prosecutors were still working with police and that no charges had been filed against Miller.
Miller said he wanted people to watch the videos and judge for themselves.
“Once they see the video, I think people realize this didn’t have to happen,” he said.
Video footage of Bland’s July traffic stop and authorities’ narrative of the incident helped fuel debate about the circumstances of her arrest and the police tactics involved. Bland, 28, who was black, argued with officers, was arrested and jailed. Days later, she was found dead in her cell, in what was later ruled a suicide. Her family has filed a wrongfuldeath suit against state and county law enforcement.
The confrontation with Miller took place less than half a mile from the site of Bland’s traffic stop.
In one of the newly released videos of Miller, which does not include audio, he can be seen stepping back as a police officer steps toward him, ordering him to retreat from his friends, Miller’s arrest came as he was preparing for homecoming weekend at Prairie View A&M University, his alma mater, about 50 miles northwest of Houston. He had spent weeks organizing a cleanup in his subdivision, and several fraternity brothers had returned to help.
About 8 p.m., three of the men, all engineers, all African American, were standing outside Miller’s apartment when police rolled up.
Miller was inside, saw the officers and emerged to meet them. He knew both officers — an African American woman and white man — from City Council meetings. He had greeted them, shaken their hands, and recently voted to give them a raise. He considered their relationship “cordial.”
“I wanted to help,” he said, to talk to the officers he knew because, “I figured that would lessen the tension.” Miller is an elementaryand middle-school teacher. The son of a retired school principal turned school board member, also a Prairie View graduate, he had never been arrested or jailed.
These were local officers who knew him, he said.
But Officer Michael Kelley didn’t want to talk.
“He just kept pushing me to move here, move there — it wouldn’t suffice,” Miller said.
Instead, Kelley ushered him away. Miller drew back, telling the officer not to touch him.
Kelley kept telling him to step farther back. Miller wasn’t sure where he was supposed to go.
“When they asked me to put my hands behind my back, I was shocked and confused,” Miller said.
The officers accused him of interfering and resisting.
“How was I interfering if I moved away?” Miller said. “Where I was standing I was in no physical way of anybody.”
In the video, Officer Penny Goodie can be heard telling Kelley not to use his taser on the councilman. Then, after changing her mind, she told Miller that he was about to be shocked with the stun gun.
Miller, who was on his knees with his back turned, said he didn’t know what was coming.
“I don’t think I was given sufficient warning,” he said, noting he was already kneeling and “in compliance.” The zap of the taser and Miller’s pained yelp can be heard on one of the videos.
Miller said he was treated well at the jail, where officials told him his case had “gone viral” on social media. When he walked out of jail Friday morning, Miller was not surprised to see an outraged crowd waiting.
“I am curious to see the videos with my fellow council members,” he said, and to hear from the police chief.
“I want to see why they think this was warranted,” Miller said.
Miller hopes police will watch the videos critically, looking for ways to improve, the way he watched videos of himself during his teacher training. “It gives them the opportunity to check themselves,” he said.
Miller said he doesn’t believe police are the enemy, but that they used excessive force. He said that the clash was a result of poor training, not racial profiling, and that police chiefs across the country should be alarmed.
“The use of excessive force, deadly force, needs to really be looked at and dissected to turn them into relationship-building opportunities rather than, ‘You do what I say or else,’ ” Miller said. “We’re people, just like them. Without that badge, we’re still people.”
The councilman has no intention of leaving Prairie View and says he feels his unpaid office is “a gift.”