Looking for help in the wrong places
Fear of raids may push migrants to unlicensed or unqualified legal consultants.
With ICE raids set to begin, migrants could be seeking advice from unqualified consultants.
President Trump’s announcement of planned immigration raids in Los Angeles and other major U.S. cities beginning Sunday has heightened fears and anxiety in targeted communities, leaving many seeking legal help susceptible to scams, advocates say.
“Announcements such as these, including the latest one of upcoming raids, unfortunately makes people scramble to find any sort of assistance,” said Jose Luis Garcia, the managing attorney at the Esperanza Immigrant Rights Project, based in Los Angeles.
Unlicensed immigration consultants, commonly known as notarios in Latin American communities, can cause serious harm to an immigrant’s legal case, experts say. This could be anyone who provides immigrationrelated services for a fee but who is not authorized to provide any sort of legal aid.
“Fear, need and anxiety are driving people to try to find some legal help,” said Rigo Reyes, the executive director of Los Angeles County’s Office of Immigrant Affairs. Immigrants are pushed to “find someone who’s going to give them the answer they want to hear, even if it’s not real,” he said.
Immigrants in the U.S. illegally are especially susceptible to scams as the threat of deportation looms. Immigration consultant offices are widely available and easily accessible, prompting many immigrants to choose unauthorized legal help over proper legal aid.
“These notarios are at every corner,” Reyes said. Also, he said, migrants may feel more comfortable with notarios. Many immigration consultants speak their native language, claim to charge less than a regular attorney and understand them culturally.
“It’s less intimidating. It feels more familiar,” he said.
Trump confirmed to reporters Friday that a nationwide Immigration and Customs Enforcement operation would begin Sunday. The raids will target undocumented immigrants with court removal orders but may also include “collateral” deportations, in which ICE agents detain those without legal status who are near those being targeted.
In some some cases, immigration consultants put their own addresses on paperwork, Reyes warned. So when a follow-up or consultation is requested by ICE officials, consultants sometimes do not inform their clients, causing them to miss court dates, or resulting in other harmful consequences that can lead to an order of removal, he said.
In 2018, the Los Angeles County Department of Consumer and Business Affairs received 270 complaints against immigration consultants, which showed a significant increase from previous years, Reyes said.
At the Esperanza Immigrant Rights Project, staff attorneys and others are gearing up for the possibility of ICE raids Sunday by reaching out to clients and family members who have pending orders of removal to keep track of their names and case numbers. They are also providing their clients with information about how to seek out authorized legal help — and showing them what legal immigration aid looks like.
“We make sure to tell them: Always ask about the individual’s background, ask for a [California Bar Assn.] card, make sure to keep all your original documents, be wary of signing blank forms,” Garcia said. “And above all, ask questions.”
Meanwhile, officials in many of the targeted cities nationwide issued statements of support for their immigrant communities and advised them of their rights and where they could seek legal aid.
Appearing on CNN’s “Anderson Cooper 360” on Friday evening, Los Angeles Mayor Eric Garcetti criticized the ICE operation as chaotic and inhumane, disrupting the lives of many.
“These are people going to church wondering if there’s going to be somebody when they come out of services. These are folks going to a park, a picnic, celebrating birthdays,” Garcetti said. “It will spread fear to that entire community and to the U.S. citizens that are a part of their families.”
On Saturday, the mayor sent this Twitter message to “all Angelenos: Here in Los Angeles, we will not be coordinating with ICE. Your city is on your side, we are in this together.”
In Houston, Mayor Sylvester Turner said in a statement that “the president’s order for concentrated ICE raids against immigrant families in Houston and elsewhere stands against everything we represent as a welcoming city. I do not support raids against innocent people who have come to this country to escape violence in their homeland or have come here to build a better life for their families. As mayor, I stand with all Houstonians regardless of their documentation status.
"Our job is to keep the city running and maintain public safety in our neighborhoods. Our job is not to be ICE — we do not deport people or break up families.”
Democratic Houston congresswoman Sheila Jackson Lee joined pastors from about 10 local churches Saturday announcing that they would offer sanctuary to migrants ahead of ICE raids.
Jackson Lee condemned the raids as “the misuse of an immigration system that’s already broken” and said it was the first time she had seen churches welcome migrants ahead of a raid in Houston, which is not a “sanctuary city.”
“We want to be a beacon of light for those who may be in fear,” said the Rev. Robert Stearns of Living Waters Apostolic Ministries, where pastors met Jackson Lee and migrant activists late Saturday to announce their plans in the food pantry.
New York Mayor Bill de Blasio tweeted Saturday in English and Spanish about the threat of ICE raids and advised immigrant communities about where they can get help.
“If you or a loved one are approached by federal immigration enforcement in your home, on the street, or in public, remember,” he said, “you have rights.”