Suit seeks to speed housing on VA campus in West L.A.
Filed on behalf of homeless veterans, litigation demands that U.S. provide more permanent homes and supportive services.
Fourteen veterans filed a lawsuit in federal court last week demanding that the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs provide permanent housing for thousands of homeless veterans on and around its West Los Angeles campus and take steps to ensure that portions of property leased to outside organizations are used primarily for veterans.
The lawsuit, prepared by Public Counsel, the Inner City Law Center and two private law firms, also names the National Veterans Foundation as a plaintiff and seeks housing for thousands of veterans it serves who suffer from serious mental illness, traumatic brain injury or post-traumatic stress syndrome.
Attorneys for the veterans are seeking an order giving the agency six months to create 1,200 homes on the 388-acre West Los Angeles campus, lease an additional 2,500 units in apartments within a five-mile radius and provide supportive services.
The VA could do that by speeding up the renovation of dozens of abandoned buildings on the property in accordance with a 2015 master plan or by rapidly constructing new housing as the military does in combat zones, said one of the plaintiff ’s attorneys, Eve Hill of the Baltimore and Washington law firm Brown, Goldstein & Levy.
The VA’s failure to provide supportive housing forces those veterans to “accept institutionalization or go without services,” the lawsuit said.
“Whether you put a big part of those on the campus, how you divide them up, where you put people, that’s all flexible,” Hill said. “It’s the outcome that is the important part.”
To overcome obstacles to finding available apartments for subsidized tenants, the agency could raise the amount paid by vouchers, increase outreach services and offer better landlord incentives, Hill said.
In a statement Wednesday, the VA declined to comment on ongoing litigation but said it “will not rest until every veteran has a good, safe, stable home in this country they fought to defend.” It said the agency has provided more than 950 permanent housing placements to L.A. veterans this year and is expecting to open 179 new units on the West L.A. campus early next year and more than 500 by year’s end, in addition to 138 that opened this year.
Much of the 106-page complaint, filed electronically Nov. 15 in U.S. District Court in Los Angeles, tells the stories of the 14 individual plaintiffs such as Lavon Johnson, the son of two military service members. Johnson enlisted in the Army as a teenager and served nearly five years, including in Iraq, but has been homeless for the 10 years since his honorable discharge.
He has been treated at the VA for mental illness and anger issues while living in the former homeless encampment just outside the VA grounds on San Vicente Boulevard, the lawsuit said.
He was known for playing classical music on a piano he rescued from the trash. Johnson moved into an 8foot-by-8-foot structure in the tiny-home interim village the VA set up when the encampment was cleared last November. The piano was put in a storeroom that has been locked when he has tried to use it.
The lawsuit contends that those tiny homes are “so institutional as to be carceral. Residents are forced to undergo searches, are denied visitors, and are surrounded by fencing and security.”
The plaintiffs deserve real homes, Hill said. “They can’t be institutions.”
The lawsuit alleges that the VA has for decades neglected the mental health of thousands of veterans by maintaining a service system that they cannot access because they do not have housing.
“The phrase ‘homeless veteran’ should be an American oxymoron,” it said. “But this is the cruel truth — the federal government consistently refuses to keep its word and take meaningful actions to bring the abomination of veteran homelessness to an end.”
Instead, it added, “the VA provides institutional services and temporary housing, leaving veterans with Serious Mental Illness and TBI [traumatic brain injury] who could live in community-based Permanent Supportive Housing with no options but to accept institutionalization or go without services. As a result, the VA remains a principal cause of continuing homelessness among veterans.”
The lawsuit also seeks to require the VA to ensure that portions of the campus leased to UCLA, nearby Brentwood School, a parking lot company and an oildrilling company are used primarily for veterans.
“The VA has failed even to consult veterans about plans to construct, and recently expand, UCLA’s state-of-the-art baseball facilities on land where the VA is required to build Permanent Supportive Housing,” the lawsuit said. As a sop to veterans, it said, the facility offers them free parking.
“Veterans must console themselves with the fact that they can park for free where they should have homes.”
A 2021 VA Office of Inspector General report found that several of those leases were out of compliance with the VA’s legal obligation to use the land to “principally benefit veterans and their families.”
“As a result of these land use deals, veterans have limited access to, or are restricted altogether from much of the WLA Campus and that land is consequently unavailable to provide housing to veterans or otherwise expand the services offered to veterans on the WLA Campus,” the lawsuit said.
The lawsuit builds on promises the VA made in settling a 2011 case brought by 10 veterans with severe disabilities. The VA agreed to draft and implement a master plan to provide housing and supportive services for veterans, setting a goal of 480 units in four years.
Last November, the VA inspector general took the agency to task for completing only one building, with 55 housing units, out of the 480.
“Reasons for VA’s limited progress include required environmental impact studies, needed infrastructure upgrades, the need to establish a principal developer enhanced-use lease, and challenges faced by the developers in raising needed funds from public and private sources,” the inspector general found.
Attorneys handling the lawsuit say those are not valid excuses.
“If you can build housing for veterans in Afghanistan and Baghdad, you can also do it in Los Angeles,” said Mark Rosenbaum, attorney for Public Counsel.
“Every president, regardless of party, has committed to ending veteran homelessness,” Rosenbaum said. “What we’re saying to the president of the United States is follow through on what you said.”