National hate crime report has major flaw
FBI data for 2021 exclude statistics from more than a third of the country’s law enforcement agencies.
The FBI on Monday released its 2021 tally of hate crimes, but the report falls dramatically short of offering an accurate national snapshot: It excludes data from a swath of law enforcement agencies, including those of Los Angeles and New York.
The FBI’s annual roundup of hate crimes statistics was based on data from 65% of the nation’s roughly 18,800 law enforcement agencies — down from 93% in 2020.
Even so, the annual report documented 7,262 criminal incidents motivated by race, religion, sexual orientation or other factors in 2021 — fewer than the 8,263 in 2020 but high considering the lapse in agency participation.
Associate Atty. Gen. Vanita Gupta attributed the decline in data from key metropolitan areas and states to a technological shift. The federal agency recently switched to a different format for law enforcement agencies to report crime data under the National Incident-Based Reporting System, or NIBRS, and agencies that had not yet transitioned were unable to submit their statistics on hate crimes to the FBI.
“The Justice Department continues to work with the nation’s law enforcement agencies to increase the reporting of hate crime statistics to the FBI to ensure we have the data to help accurately identify and prevent hate crimes,” Gupta said in a statement.
The absence of a third of law enforcement agencies — including those of some of the largest U.S. cities — makes it tricky for criminologists, policymakers and historians to draw meaningful conclusions about national hate crime trends.
In California, only 15 of 740 law enforcement agencies submitted 2021 data to the FBI through the new system. That meant only 73 hate crime incidents were tallied in the state by the FBI — far fewer than the 1,339 documented by the bureau in 2020.
Participation was even lower in Florida: Only two of 757 law enforcement agencies there submitted data via the new portal, and only one hate crime was reported.
Some experts say the FBI report should never have been published.
“It’s a critically f lawed, incomplete document that fails to capture the fundamental elements that criminologists want to know,” said Brian Levin, director of the Center for the Study of Hate and Extremism at Cal State San Bernardino, who urged the FBI to amend the report. “You can’t leave out nearly all of California and Florida!”
Levin said the FBI statistics did not capture what he believes to be a significant national rise in hate crimes. If just New York City and California’s 2021 figures were added to the mix, the national totals would jump past 9,000 for only the second time since the FBI began collecting data on hate crimes in 1991.
Levin, who compiles his own database of hate crimes, drawn from Freedom of Information Act requests and agency websites, noted that much of the information is not difficult to obtain. In June, the California attorney general’s office announced that there had been a surge of 1,763 hate crimes in 2021.
The decline in the number of participating agencies — many of them among the highest-reporting and reliable ones — makes the FBI report “unintentionally deceptive” in documenting overall trends, Levin said. It also fails to accurately represent increases in reported attacks against particular groups, such as Asians and Jews.
Earlier this year, the Center for the Study of Hate and Extremism published a report that showed a 20% increase in hate crimes in 2021, with a 224% increase in antiAsian crime.
“We were looking at a record year for anti-Asian hate crimes,” Levin said. “We counted more anti-Asian hate crimes in just 21 cities than the FBI counted nationwide.”
While the FBI showed a reduction in hate crimes against Jews, he said, his own group’s research found a significant increase.
The FBI is required by federal law to collect data on hate crimes from federal, state, local, tribal and university law enforcement agencies as part of the Uniform Crime Reporting program. But participation is mandatory only for federal law enforcement.
Summarizing the 2021 data, the FBI said that 65% of victims were targeted because of the offenders’ bias against their race, ethnicity or ancestry; 16% due to sexual orientation; 13% due to religion; and 4% due to gender identity.
The FBI also noted that more agencies were using NIBRS in 2022.
“As more agencies transition to the NIBRS data collection with continued support from the Department of Justice, hate crime statistics in coming years will provide a richer and more complete picture of hate crimes nationwide,” the agency said in a statement.
Some civil rights groups condemned law enforcement agencies’ failure to provide local information via the NIBRS system.
“The failure of thousands of police agencies across the country to participate in this report is devastating for the individuals and communities harmed by these crimes and to our ability to understand and prevent them,” Margaret Huang, president and chief executive of the Southern Poverty Law Center, said in a statement.
Until legislation requires law enforcement agencies to report hate crimes, Huang said, federal funds to agencies should be conditioned on thorough reporting of such crimes or on meaningful community prevention.
“We can and must do better,” Huang said.
Orlando Martinez, the hate crimes coordinator for the Los Angeles Police Department, said his agency is working on installing the NIBRS system but did not yet have it in place.
Still, he emphasized that his agency was not holding anything back: It submitted hate crime statistics to the California Department of Justice.
In 2021, Martinez said, LAPD reported 616 hate crime incidents, versus 359 in 2020.
“Even though we’re not in the computer database that everybody’s looking at, they have our stats,” Martinez said. “It is just not in that format.”
Just last week, a report released by the L.A. County Commission on Human Relations found that hate crimes in 2021 climbed by 20% over 2020 to their highest level in 20 years. Racially motivated crimes in the county jumped 17%, the report said, with Black people comprising nearly half of the victims.
A key reason for the spike is that Los Angeles County has made it easier to report hate crimes in recent years. In 2020, officials launched the program L.A. vs. Hate, which includes a hotline for reporting “acts of verbal or physical aggression, refusal of service, bullying or intimidation of any kind that is motivated by hostile prejudice.”
Civil rights advocates have long complained that the FBI figures are an undercount.
Local police forces, they argue, are insufficiently trained in how to identify hate crimes and frequently do not have enough motivation or resources to investigate allegations. Another challenge is that victims of hate crimes don’t always report them to the police.
“The data need not be perfect,” Levin said. “But when it is this incomplete, it becomes an obstacle, because the average American will look at it and say, ‘Oh, OK, hate crimes are down.’ ”