Marysville Appeal-Democrat

California­ns won’t willingly give up cars

- By Thomas D. Elias

Since the early 1970s time of ex-gov. Jerry Brown’s first term in office, California officials from the top down have tried to coax California­ns out of their cars.

It began with Brown’s installing as his highway czarina the highly touted “transporta­tion genius” Adriana Gianturco, a Harvard Graduate School product whose first step was to turn two existing lanes of the world’s busiest roadway – the I-10 Santa Monica Freeway in Los Angeles – over to carpools only.

This won her the determined enmity of most local motorists, who soon hounded Gianturco from office and away from California, while the lanes went back to general use and the “Giant Turkey” became a cautionary tale for bureaucrat­s who followed.

This 44-year-old lesson appears all but forgotten today, as state and local government­s obsess over the notion that mass transit and dense developmen­t can somehow lessen traffic gridlock.

That’s one rationale behind all the bicycle lanes appearing in cities large and small today, often at the expense of traffic lanes and parking spaces. It’s also the reasoning that drives efforts to force dense housing near light rail stations and heavily used bus routes, on the presumptio­n that new occupants will not add to traffic, using mass transit instead.

The problem: Among California cities, only San Francisco has anything like the comprehens­ive public transporta­tion system needed to accomplish this. As a result, gridlock is now worse than ever in most cities, including San Francisco, where one recent study showed ridesharin­g vehicles from outfits like Uber and Lyft make up 30 percent of all traffic.

Which means some residents have indeed been driven from their cars – right into other cars. There is no reduction in smog from this; in fact, narrowed streets produce more greenhouse gases than before as cars idle far longer at stoplights because of slower traffic flow caused by transforme­d traffic lanes. The current profusion of sport utility vehicles doesn’t help, either, as they take up significan­tly more space than sedans and slow things even more.

Even the presence of new rail lines doesn’t guarantee more mass transit riders. Last year, the Metropolit­an Transit Authority of Southern California (MTA) found opening the new Expo Line from downtown Los Angeles to the beach increased train ridership – but bus occupancy on parallel routes was down by similar amounts. A net of virtually

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States