Miami Herald

CASH AND A SHOT

- BY KARIN KLEIN Los Angeles Times Karin Klein is a Los Angeles Times editorial board member. (c)2021 Los Angeles Times

It has become increasing­ly clear that Gov. Ron DeSantis is awarding vaccines on a pay-to-play basis. This was true for the 1,200 residents of wealthy Ocean Reef, who got their vaccinatio­ns in mid-January when vaccines were in short supply and there wasn’t much to go around.

Though he denies he authorized this distributi­on, the medical center that received and administer­ed the vaccines contradict­s his denial.

DeSantis has set himself up as a vaccine czar. Instead of targeting vaccines based on need and fairness, he is directing many of them to areas where wealthy donors live, while his political committee has raised more than $3.9 million from them.

This is nothing but obscene; it smells of corruption. Democrats are right to call for a federal investigat­ion.

DeSantis’ handling of the whole COVID crisis has been riddled with deception, and he must be held accountabl­e. Floridians need to wake up to this. His actions are hurting most of us.

– Kenneth Barnes, Miami

EBay allows people to sell Adolf Hitler’s “Mein Kampf” on its site, as well as the infamously false and anti-Semitic “Protocols of the Elders of Zion.” “Peter Pan,” laden with stereotype­s about Native Americans, is for sale there, along with the many books of the “Little House on the Prairie” series, which includes minstrel shows, refers to Black people as “darkies” and contains many negative depictions of Native Americans — even though the white protagonis­ts were illegally squatting on Indian land.

And it’s fine that all of these are sold. Terrible books with troubling content shouldn’t be erased from all memory. So how is it that the six discontinu­ed books by Dr. Seuss are now banned from auction or sale on the site?

That’s what the site has announced, after prices on the books shot up to the clouds on the news that they wouldn’t be printed because of racist imagery and some racist wording.

Dr. Seuss Enterprise­s decided to stop publishing those books, but not all books with racist content should be banned. Most adults are smart enough to know the difference between acceptable and deplorable depictions of marginaliz­ed people, and how much of the latter comes from eras in which the deplorable was accepted — and far too often celebrated.

Not that we’ve gotten past that time, but as a society, many of us are trying.

But these Seuss books were written for preschoole­rs and primary-grade students. They generally were read time and again by the same children, meaning that racist depictions of Chinese people wearing coolie hats and Africans with hoops in their noses were impressed deeply into their minds, and for many might have formed their first impression­s of these groups.

People who are forking over hundreds of dollars for a copy of “If I Ran the

Zoo” aren’t doing it for the perverse pleasure of showering young minds with racist propaganda. They’re snapping up what they think will be a valuable collectibl­e, or simply because of nostalgic fondness for the entire Seuss oeuvre, so that the books won’t entirely disappear.

I get it. At a library usedbook sale decades ago, I bought an early edition of Ogden Nash’s “Adventures of Isabel,” a lively rhyming tale about a gutsy little girl who faces down nightmares, bears and the like. In one scenario, she’s being treated by a Black doctor who punches and pokes her and tries to get her to take a pill. Isabel doesn’t comply; she turns around and “cures the doctor.” Curing him, it turns out, turns him into a white man.

I read the book to my older kids, wincing at that particular page but, to my shame, never just tossing the book. Sometimes I skipped over the offending part, but of course the kids would note my “mistake” and demand that I turn back to it. Finally, I shelved the book, but I didn’t throw it out. It’s a reminder of the twisted concepts we never thought much about, even if we considered ourselves nonracists.

The decision to discontinu­e the books was made by the organizati­on in charge of Dr. Seuss’ legacy, and it was the right one. Those books no longer have a proper place on a young child’s bookshelf. It’s a different matter to prevent adults who want to collect books from being able to purchase copies of them.

This is an obvious attempt by eBay to brand itself as an anti-racist company, and it’s well within its legal rights to refuse to allow the sale of whatever it wants. But because the venues for purchasing these books are now extremely limited, it also acts as a kind of censor of which books people can decide to collect and place on their shelves, and that’s a shame — and downright hypocritic­al. If eBay truly thinks that banning offensive books on its site makes it look better, it had better check out a lot more of the offerings up for auction there.

 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States