Miami Herald

Racism came home to roost at the Florida Capitol


Florida lawmakers got a taste of the bigotry their legislatio­n has helped to legitimize in the past two years of warring against so-called “woke” culture.

The latest effort, a bill to prohibit local government­s from removing historic monuments, appears to have floundered after a heated Senate committee hearing on Tuesday. The bill would prevent local elected officials from ordering Confederat­e statues taken down, threatenin­g those officials with fines of up to $1,000 and potential civil lawsuits.

It took one comment from a supporter of the bill to crack the facade that Senate Bill 1122 is merely about preserving history. While some lawmakers might believe that’s what they are doing, they cannot ignore the message they are sending to racists and white supremacis­ts.

The message is that the Legislatur­e will protect the wishes of people who want to celebrate a Confederac­y that fought to preserve slavery at the expense of Black Floridians who see it a symbol of hatred.


During public comments, a bill supporter said the movement to remove Confederat­e monuments “is part of the cultural war being waged against white society.” The comment, from a member of the audience, made not only Democrats uncomforta­ble — they walked out of the committee room in protest before a vote — but also Republican­s. Another speaker said that if Native Americans found out they had “standing” to take down Spanish statues in places like St. Augustine, there wouldn’t be any left in the state.

“The comments that I heard today... they were bigoted, they were racist,” Republican Sen. Jennifer Bradley said. “And you are the reason I’m vacillatin­g on whether or not to even vote yes. Because it looks like I endorse your hatred, and I do not.”

Neverthele­ss, Bradley still voted “yes” on the bill, as did every other

Republican on the Senate Committee on Community Affairs, including Chair Alexis Calatayud, of Miami, who was taken aback by the “white culture” comment, telling the audience member that other bill supporters don’t agree with his position.

After the committee hearing, however, Republican Senate President Kathleen Passidomo put the bill’s fate into question.

“There are problems with the bill,” Passidomo said. “More than that, there are problems with the perception­s among our caucus, on all sides... I’m not going to bring a bill to the floor that is so abhorrent to everybody.”

We give Passidomo credit for reading the room, but her actions are more important than her words. Sure, there are problems — a lot of them — with the bill, beginning with its conception. This is not the type of legislatio­n that can be fixed with an amendment. It should be allowed to languish and die.

People have different feelings about taking down Confederat­e monuments, and certainly some who want to preserve them aren’t white nationalis­ts. There’s a valid debate on how far communitie­s should go in taking down monuments of historic figures who held slaves or abhorrent racist views.

The problem with this bill is that it takes away local government­s’ authority to make those decisions based on the wishes of their communitie­s. In December, the mayor of Jacksonvil­le, a city that’s 30% Black, ordered the removal of a Confederat­e statue from a park. Just months before that, the city was the site of a mass shooting where three Black people were killed because of their race.

Despite tragedies like this (or the 2015 Charleston Black church shooting by a white supremacis­t who posed for photos with the Confederat­e flag), Florida lawmakers insist on pushing legislatio­n like SB 1122 or the “Stop WOKE Act,” which limited classroom instructio­n on racism. Meanwhile, Gov. Ron DeSantis has refused to properly denounce neo-Nazi marches that happened in Central Florida over the past two years.

That might not be their intention but the Florida Legislatur­e and DeSantis have emboldened racists. This is what critics have been warning against all along. Now that racism reared its ugly head publicly — and in their faces — perhaps Republican­s will understand what they have unleashed.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States