Trial date in Haiti assassination case is likely to be delayed for months
A historic Miami trial spotlighting the assassination of Haiti’s president will likely be held months after its scheduled date in May for the remaining five defendants who have not reached plea deals with federal prosecutors.
On Tuesday, prosecutors told a judge they’re willing to delay the trial until October. But defense attorneys said they needed even more time — until March of next year — citing the huge volume of evidence, the logistical challenge of meeting with their clients in a federal lock-up and the backdrop of the extraordinary turmoil in Haiti.
Jacqueline Becerra, the newly confirmed judge who was handed the remainder of the case by veteran jurist Jose Martinez on Tuesday, ordered both sides to make their arguments for a new trial date in writing. But she made her timeline clear.
“It looks like a continuance [of the trial] is in order, but I’d be surprised if it’s going to be a year,” said Becerra, who, as a magistrate judge, had been reviewing some of the pretrial motions.
The high-profile U.S. case is at a crossroads: five of the 11 defendants have pleaded guilty to conspiring to kill Haiti’s president, Jovenel Moïse, on July 7, 2021, resulting in life sentences that they hope to get reduced with their cooperation. A sixth defendant also pleaded guilty to conspiracy charges involving the smuggling of bulletproof vests that were illegally exported to Haiti for a group of Colombian exsoldiers who carried out the deadly attack.
The remaining five defendants are charged with conspiring in South Florida to kidnap or kill Haiti’s leader and related charges, including recruiting the Colombian commandos. The conspiracy charge carries up to life in prison.
The defendants facing trial are: Antonio Intriago, the head of a Miami-area security firm, CTU; Arcangel Pretel Ortiz, a former FBI informant who joined Intriago at CTU; Walter Veintemilla, a Broward County financier; James Solages, a Haitian
American; and Christian Emmanuel Sanon, a Haitian pastor and physician who was initially seen by the group as a successor to Moïse as Haiti’s president.
Last month, Sanon was charged with the others for the first time with conspiring to kill Haiti’s leader, after first being accused of trying to carry out a military expedition against a foreign country. It was the fifth superseding indictment filed by prosecutors Andrea Goldbarg, Monica Castro and Frank Russo.
At Tuesday’s hearing, attorneys for all five defendants said they needed a year or possibly even more time to prepare for trial, pointing out that the federal prosecutors are still in the process of turning over more than 2.5 million pieces of evidence, including text messages, emails and other records.
“If you gave us another year, it would still not be enough time,” said Emmanuel Perez, one of the attorneys for Intriago.
“It’s impossible for us to go to trial in the next couple of months,” he said, referring to the scheduled May 9 trial date. “It is an absolutely overwhelming amount of discovery that we have to process . ... Add to that, what’s going on with the Haitian government is unfathomable.”
Since the president’s assassination at his home outside Port-au-Prince, Haiti has plunged into total chaos as armed gangs have terrorized the island nation with no presidential election on the horizon.
While the U.S. investigation led by the FBI moved quickly, Haiti’s probe only resulted in an indictment last month. A total of 51 people were charged by an investigative judge in collaboration with a prosecutor. Among those accused of the deadly attack: the slain president’s widow, Martine Moïse, who suffered gunshot wounds during the assault at the family’s home.