Health care claim combusts
Democrats across the country have been saying on the campaign trail that the Republicans’ longstanding push to overturn the Affordable Care Act threatens insurance protections for Americans with pre-existing conditions.
The law was passed in 2010 by a Democratic-controlled Congress and signed by President Barack Obama; no Republican voted for it.
Republicans used popular dissatisfaction with the law to make significant congressional gains in the 2010 and 2014 midterm elections, but the pattern has shifted in 2018, after unsuccessful Republican efforts to repeal the law.
The Wesleyan Media Project recently found that health care was the most common subject of Democratic congressional campaign ads, the New York Times reported.
But in a rally in Rochester, Minn., on Oct. 4, President Donald Trump sought to flip this narrative on its head. He argued that it’s actually the Republicans who are the champions of pre-existing condition protections, and Democrats who are trying to kill them.
“We will always protect Americans with pre-existing conditions,” Trump said. “We’re going to take care of them. Some of the Democrats have been talking about ending pre-existing conditions. And some people have — you know what I say? We’ll get a little more money from China. It’ll be just fine. It’ll be just fine. We’ll be just fine.”
We have previously written that a pending lawsuit against the Affordable Care Act by Republican attorneys general would, if successful, end protections for pre-existing conditions.
(Such protections could be reinstated by new legislation if the courts do strike down the law, but health policy
experts say the mechanics of achieving this result in a way different from the Affordable Care Act would be tricky; the decades-long fight to protect patients with pre-existing conditions does not provide much optimism for a quick legislative fix.)
For its part, the Trump administration has decided not defend the law against the attorney generals’ suit, effectively siding with those who want to overturn the law.
The second part of Trump’s assertion, however, was new to us. Is he right that “some of the Democrats have been talking about ending pre-existing conditions”?
We found zero evidence of this. For starters, Trump’s assertion is illogical given the Democrats’ role in passing the law and Democratic efforts to hammer Republican candidates over pre-existing condition protections on the campaign trail.
Drew Hammill, a spokesman for House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., said there is no such chatter among Democratic officeholders or
We also asked independent healthpolicy experts whether they had heard any Democratic messages — or even whispers — about getting rid of preexisting condition protections. They said they had not.
“I find President Trump’s comments surprising,” said Christine Eibner, a health policy specialist at the Rand Corp.
“I can’t think of any,” said Gail Wilensky, who headed Medicare and Medicaid under President George H.W. Bush.
“No — how bad can this (rhetoric) get?” asked John Holahan, a health policy specialist at the Urban Institute.
“Unbelievable,” said Linda Blumberg, who also studies health policy at the Urban Institute. “No.”
The White House did not reply to an inquiry seeking examples. Neither did the office of the Senate majority leader or the House speaker.
Trump said, “Some of the Democrats have been talking about ending (coverage for) pre-existing conditions.”
We can’t find any examples of what Trump claimed Democrats were saying. A Democratic proposal to end preexisting conditions would run 100 percent counter to Democrats’ own history with the Affordable Care Act and would undercut one of the Democrats’ most powerful messages on the campaign trail this year.
We rate the statement Pants on Fire.