New York Daily News

THE NEWS SAYS

-

Gov Cuomo bit off a supersized mouthful in his 92-minute reelection-year State of the State speech

Not lightly did Gov. Cuomo invite the brother of the late Kalief Browder to his State of the State address — and in the name of that young man lost, who killed himself after three years of needless jailing at Rikers Island, Cuomo now proposes an urgent package of criminal justice reforms.

Eliminatin­g cash bail for some defendants, because poverty is not a crime.

Demanding that prosecutor­s deliver evidence to opposing attorneys well in advance of trials.

Speeding up absurdly sluggish trials, in a court system where, Cuomo justly complained, judges routinely clock out midday.

Stepping in to salvage or shut substandar­d jails, because no human should suffer beyond their due punishment dealt by law.

Fixing rules for discovery of evidence in criminal proceeding­s is the simplest and most morally necessary task. Too many men have been imprisoned for years on evidence that unraveled on reinspecti­on — and a common thread in many of the cases of later exoneratio­n is evidence held back in discovery until poor defendants’ ill-equipped lawyers can do nothing with it.

To focus on one recently exposed by The News: Felipe Rodriguez spent 27 years behind bars after his lawyer failed to obtain a tape of a key prosecutio­n witness contradict­ing his own account.

In enabling sneak prosecutio­ns, New York remains a shameful outlier among states and arguably undermines defendants’ constituti­onal right to a fair trial.

Rewrite the law: Require cops and prosecutor­s to share evidence with the accused, and share it as early as possible in the process.

On bail reform, Cuomo wisely steers away from the course chosen by New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie, who all but abolished cash bail a year ago. Cuomo would allow bail for serious felonies and direct pretrial detention for defendants proven to be dangerous — while using alternativ­es, electronic monitoring and the like, to get lesser defendants to show up to trial.

New York City had made such strides in supervisin­g lower-risk defendants at home that it just announced the closure of a Rikers Island jail.

It would be a mistake to see such supervised release as a panacea — the city already keeps the overwhelmi­ng majority of low-level, low-risk defendants out of jail — but just as much of an error not to attempt expansion of the kind Cuomo urges.

The state must rebalance out-of-whack scales of justice even as it helps local police and prosecutor­s drive crime, at historic lows, lower still

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States