New York Daily News

Don must give data, sez judge

- BY SPENCER S. HSU

WASHINGTON — A federal judge on Monday denied President Trump’s bid to quash a House subpoena for years of his financial records from his accounting firm and stayed his order seven days to give the president’s lawyers time to appeal.

The ruling handed an initial defeat to Trump’s vow to defy subpoenas by House Democrats and came in one of the first courtroom challenges to a series of lawmakers’ investigat­ive demands for his bank records, accounting statements and tax returns.

District Judge Amit Mehta of Washington refused to block the records request to Mazars USA from the House Oversight and Reform Committee while litigation continues. Attorneys for Trump and associated businesses filed suit April 22, arguing that Congress is not entitled to investigat­e his past personal financial dealings for potential corruption.

“So long as Congress investigat­es on a subject matter on which ‘legislatio­n could be had,’ Congress acts as contemplat­ed by Article I of the Constituti­on,” Mehta said in a 41-page opinion.

Mehta ruled that the committee’s assertions that Trump’s records will help it consider strengthen­ing ethics and disclosure laws and enforce a constituti­onal ban on acceptance of foreign gifts by a president were “facially valid,” saying, “It is not for the court to question whether the committee’s actions are truly motivated by political considerat­ions.”

In court, Douglas Letter, general counsel of the House of Representa­tives, has charged that the lawsuit would dismiss Congress’ constituti­onal oversight powers as “a nuisance ... getting in [Trump’s] way while he’s trying to run the country.”

Meanwhile, Trump’s private attorney Jay Sekulow said when the lawsuit was filed that the president’s team “will not allow congressio­nal presidenti­al harassment to go unanswered.”

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States