Critics

Disney’s live-action Mulan loses the songs but amps up the corporate nationalism.

movies by Alison Willmore Live-action Mulan is a dour drag tv by Kathryn VanArendonk The Boys transcends the dark, gritty superhero slog theater by Helen Shaw Coastal Elites embodies all of filmed theater’s worst qualities

mulan doesn’t sing “Reflection” anymore. In fact, no one sings in the new live-action remake of Mulan, which trades the 1998 film’s musical numbers for wuxia-inflected action scenes and only deploys its most famous ballad to underscore select pivotal moments for its heroine. The 2020 Mulan, played by Liu Yifei, is made of sterner stuff than her animated predecessor, a character from the tail end of the Disney Renaissance era who was adapted from a Chinese folktale about a young woman who disguises herself as a man to take her infirm father’s place when he is conscripted to serve in the emperor’s army. Mulan has become a princess without an “I wish” song, which feels, in some way, fitting—she was never a royal to begin with, and now she’s caught between the time-tested formulas of an American entertainment giant and what that entertainment giant believes will appeal to a Chinese audience. It’s impossible to articulate what, exactly, this iteration of Mulan is wishing for.

Disney’s live-action remakes of its animated hits have become one of the more cynical and successful endeavors in recent cinematic