New York Post

‘ True story’ fudges the truth and bungles the story

- twitter.com/loulumenic­k

D ID you know that a “straight-acting” Kansas farm boy threw the first brick in the riot that sparked the modern gay-rights movement? News to me, and probably most other New Yorkers.

Roland Emmerich’s seriously misguided “Stonewall’’ reduces the transgende­r drag queens who helped change America to dress extras in what’s basically a Big Apple retelling of “The Wizard of Oz’’ revolving around a Caucasian gay man’s coming of age.

Already accepted to Columbia University, teenage Danny (Jeremy Irvine) is kicked out of town by his football-coach dad after his high-school teammates see him servicing the team’s hunky quarterbac­k.

Danny’s sleeping on a park bench in Sheridan Square when Hispanic transgende­r woman Ramona (Jonny Beauchamp) invites him to share a crash pad with her flamboyant pals (all played by non-trans actors) on Christophe­r Street.

Ramona has a crush on clean-cut Danny, whose own taste in men runs more toward to wa Trevor (Jonathan Rhy ys Meyers), a ripped gay-righ hts activist he meets at the e Stonewall Inn. That’s th he soon-to-be-infamous mob-owned-m drag bar managed by Murphy (Ron Perlman), who has half the officers at the 6th Precinct on his payroll so he can disappeard during police ra aids, where his customers s are arrested and/or humiliated for wearing women’s clothing.

Danny learns he’s not in Kansas anymore while turning tricks to support himself and getting beaten by leering cops while cruising the Meatpackin­g District. Neverthele­ss, Emmerich keeps returning to the Midwest for flashbacks, as well as for a lengthy epilogue.

Back at the Stonewall, the NYPD’s Public Morals squad, led by Inspector Pine (Matt Craven), stages an unschedule­d raid while the regulars are mourning the death of Judy Garland. They’ve finally had enough, and their battle with the cops is the best-staged part of the film — even if the realistica­lly detailed Sheridan Square set in a Montreal studio looks notably smaller than the real thing.

Emmerich — a hugely successful director of disaster movies who happens to be gay — deserves credit for trying to call attention to the plight of gay homeless youth in this self-financed, if seriously flawed, labor of love. But with thinly drawn characters, uneven performanc­es and tin-eared dialogue, “Stonewall’’ plays at best like a musical without the songs.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States