New York Post

Mayoral control in hot seat

Pols to mull renewal

- By CARL CAMPANILE ccampanile@nypost.com

The state Assembly plans to hold a hearing in mid-December on whether mayoral control of the New York City school system should be extended or gutted when the law comes up for renewal in 2022.

“There are some people who want major changes to the law,” Assembly Education Committee Chairman Michael Benedetto (D-Bronx) told The Post.

“We made a promise to have hearings on what school governance should look like in New York City in the future. We’re going to look at other school-governance models, what other major school districts are doing.”

Mayoral school control was initially championed by then-Mayor Mike Bloomberg and approved by the state Legislatur­e in 2002. It has been renewed several times since, including last year.

Mayor de Blasio also has been a big booster.

The law abolished the muchmalign­ed Board of Education, gave the mayor sole authority to hire the schools chancellor and also gave City Hall the power to appoint a eight of the 13 members of a revamped board to set education policy.

The move also turned the Department of Education into a city agency and eliminated 32 locally elected community school boards following years of mismanagem­ent and corruption scandals.

Under the old system, the seven members of the Board of Education — five appointed by the borough presidents and two by the mayor — chose the chancellor and were in charge of policy.

Teachers-union head Mike Mulgrew wants to strip the mayor of sole control over schools and move back to an arrangemen­t akin to the old governance model.

“We need a change. Parents and educators need more voice. A single person in control, with few checks and balances, is not good for our school system,” Mulgrew, the president of the United Federation of Teachers, told The Post last week.

The law expires in June 2022, after de Blasio leaves office.

Mulgrew’s plan calls for the mayor to choose five members of the Panel for Education Policy, with the remaining picks going to each of the five borough presidents, the city comptrolle­r, the City Council speaker and the public advocate.

The members would also serve staggered, three-year terms with an option for renewal, rather than at the pleasure of whoever appointed them.

In addition, Mulgrew wants the panel to conduct initial searches for new schools chancellor­s, then screen the candidates and have the mayor choose from among the top three finishers.

The mayor now selects the chancellor without getting names from the panel.

Bloomberg used the law to close low-performing schools and open more charter schools and smaller high schools. He also used his expanded powers to tighten the city’s promotiona­l and accountabl­e policies tied to results on standardiz­ed tests.

De Blasio used his authority under the same law to dramatical­ly expand the city’s pre-K program and reverse Bloomberg’s testheavy accountabi­lity programs.

He also launched a $773 million Renewal program to try to turn around low-performing schools instead of closing them, with mixed results.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States