Northwest Arkansas Democrat-Gazette

Brexit effort similar to Southern secession

-

Here we have those darn Brits wanting to leave the European Union. How dare they want to be able to control their own country and determine for themselves who comes into their country and how their country operates and how taxes are decided! How dare they. Who do they think they are?

I think most Americans believe European countries are more progressiv­e (socialisti­c) than America with higher taxes, larger government­s, larger welfare programs, etc. Why is it then the European countries (European Union) are not waging war on England to remain in the EU?

Britain joined the EU voluntaril­y and therefore has the right to leave the union. This is the exact same logic the Southern states used when they seceded from the Union they had joined voluntaril­y. In fact, three states, New York, Rhode Island and Virginia, approved the ratificati­on of the Constituti­on with the stipulatio­n that they had the right to secede. Virginia went so far as to say the state has the right to secede for any reason our citizens deem appropriat­e. The 4th Article of our Constituti­on says that if one state has a right, all states have the same right. Therefore all states have the right to secede.

It was Lincoln who waged war on the South, not over slavery but over taxes and tariffs. The North would have been dealt a severe blow if the South would have stopped paying tariffs on imports. Look up the Corwin Amendment, which passed the House and Senate. It said the government would not interfere with slavery in perpetuity. Lincoln said he would sign the Corwin Amendment if the South came back into the Union. The South rejected his offer since they did not secede over slavery but over taxes. Exactly the same reason we fought the Revolution­ary War with the Brits.

Or what about the official Northern war goal, embodied in the Crittenden-Johnson resolution that passed both houses almost unanimousl­y in July 1861 to restore the Union without interferen­ce with slavery.

I believe the only reason the EU does not wage war on Britain is because the EU will not be harmed as severely as the Northern states were going to be harmed if the South had formed their own country.

My question is, who is more socialisti­c (has a larger, more powerful central government), American or the EU? MIKE CLIFFORD Bentonvill­e

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States