South Africa blasts Trump’s tweet as false, divisive
Comment focused on white farmers
JOHANNESBURG — South Africa’s government lashed out at President Donald Trump on Thursday after he tweeted that his administration would be looking into alleged seizures of white-owned farms and the “large scale killing of farmers” in the country, an assertion it said was false and “only seeks to divide our nation and remind us of our colonial past.”
Mr. Trump’s statements drew praise Thursday from white nationalists and protests from anti-racism groups.
South Africa is in the throes of a racially charged national debate over land reform, a lawful process that seeks to correct the legacy of decades of white minority rule that stripped blacks of their land. Today, nearly a quarter-century after the first democratic elections, black South Africans comprise 80 percent of the population but own 4 percent of the country’s land, according to the government.
Though the ruling African National Congress has pledged to close that gap, progress has been slow. In July, South Africa President Cyril Ramaphosa said his party would amend the constitution so the state could expropriate land without compensation to speed up the land reform process, but that has not yet happened and no land has been seized.
Mr. Trump’s tweet followed a segment on Fox News on Wednesday in which host Tucker Carlson claimed Mr. Ramaphosa had already started “seizing land from his own citizens without compensation because they are the wrong skin color,” calling the alleged seizures “immoral.”
The government said Mr. Trump’s tweet was based on “false information” and reflected a “narrow perception which only seeks to divide our nation and reminds us of our colonial past.” It called a meeting with officials at the U.S. Embassy as it sought to clarifyMr. Trump’s remarks.
Though no land seizures have occurred, the prospect has sent panic through some white farming communities who worry the policy will strip them of their land, cause land prices to plummet or makethem the target of potentiallyviolent land seizures.
For years, a small but vocal group of white South Africans have claimed white farmers are the target of violent, raciallymotivated farm attacks.
Experts say the attacks reflect the country’s generally high crime rate and there is no evidence connecting them to the victims’ race.
Farm murders have been declining since their peak in 2001, according to research by AgriSA, an umbrella group of South African agricultural associations. In 2016-17, there were 74 murders during farm attacks, according to Africa Check, compared to 19,000 murders across the country in the same period.
“People are not being targeted because of their race, but because they are vulnerable and isolated on the farms,” said Gareth Newham, head of the crime and justice program at the Institute for Security Studies in the capital, Pretoria.
“There is no white genocide in South Africa,” Julius Malema, leader of the opposition Economic Freedom Fighters party, told reporters. “There is black genocide in the USA; black people are killed every day. There is a black genocide here in South Africa; just recently a farmer was convicted for the murder of a black farmer.”
Mr. Trump’s tweet had some supporters.
AfriForum, a group that represents some white South African interests, welcomed his comments. In May, its leaders went to the U.S. to lobby officials and institutions about Mr. Ramaphosa’s proposal to expropriate land and the alleged targeting of white farmers.
Earlier this month, the group posted a list of farms it said were earmarked for expropriation, a list the government said is fake.
“Everyone in South Africa should … hope that the pressure from the USA will lead to the [ruling party] reconsidering the disastrous route that they want to take South Africa on,” AfriForum CEO Kallie Kriel said in a statement Thursday.
AfriForum and other critics say the government’s proposal to expropriate land without compensation could lead to economic disaster, pointing to the collapse of the agricultural sector in neighboring Zimbabwe after the government of former President Robert Mugabe began seizing white-owned farms, sometimes violently, in 2000.
“We are going to take back the land and we’ll do it by any means necessary,” said Lindsay Maasdorp, national spokesman for Black First Land First, a group that condones land seizures in South Africa.
Proponents of South Africa’s policy, including Mr. Ramaphosa, say it is necessary to address historic injustices and can be done in a way that is lawful and will not compromise the beleaguered economy or food security.
“It is absolutely unbelievable that a head of state at that level can be so disrespectful to issues of dispossession that South Africa is painfully trying to address in a democratic way,” Vuyo Mahlati, president of the African Farmers’ Association of South Africa, said of Mr. Trump.
Later on Thursday in Washington, the State Department toned down Mr. Trump’s language suggesting that massive land seizures were underway. Spokeswoman Heather Nauert said expropriating land without compensation “would risk sending South Africa down the wrong path,” but she did not repeat the president’s suggestion that large numbers of white South African farmers hadbeen killed.
Also on Thursday, Republican Sen. Jeff Flake of Arizona, chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations subcommittee on Africa, challenged Mr. Trump’s grasp of the facts on farmer killings and urged him not to tweet about foreign policy using information from “one news report.” The senator is a frequent Trump critic who is retiring at the end of his current term.
Some observers say Mr. Trump is using his latest Africa comments to try to deflect attention from his sprawling legal troubles at home.
“The President of the U.S. needs political distractions to turn our gaze away from his criminal cabal, and so he’s attackingSouth Africa with the disproven racial myth of ‘large scale killings of farmers,’” Patrick Gaspard, a former U.S. ambassador to South Africa, tweeted Thursday. “This man ... has no discernible Africa policy.”
In parliament on Wednesday, Mr. Ramaphosa said land expropriation could make more land available for cultivation, and that the process would begin by seizing state-owned land, not privately held land.
Mr. Trump has never experienced apartheid and doesn’t know its legacy of inequality in which the majority of South Africans own nothing, Zizi Kodwa, a member of the ruling party’s national executive committee, told The Associated Press.
The Washington Post and Los Angeles Times contributed.